Reviews for Mattakeese Wharf Seafood Restaurant in Barnstable, MA

I never do this but... we paid $48 for a lobster roll today that was covered with too much Mayo and used all the rubbery parts... from the claws that have no flavor. You know, the parts nobody eats or wants! That was the entire roll! Been loving lobsterrolls for years and this was the worst we've ever had and the most expensive! It Was Absolutely Awful. The side of potato saladhad no flavor. Ordered a Coke but they only carry generic flavor coca-cola and other generic flavors and brands that we'venever heard from. It was sweet sugar and it was flat. Ceaser salad was fine, shrimp cocktail was shop and stop previouslyfrozen caliber (no offense). Awful meal. The one star is for our delightful server. Read more

Fun restaurant with cool views. The homemade chips with blue cheese and bacon is a great appetizer. If they have the swordfish... chop as a special, you won’t be disappointed. The pasta Livorno is also pretty great. Read more

Absolutely delightful waterfront seafood restaurant. The martinis and cocktails are amazing. And both of our seafood dishes were... delicious. Even the sides were well prepared and flavorful. We sat indoors but they had all the windows open (there are screens)and there was an incredible breeze blowing through. Nice view of the boat ramp. The waitress did a very good job. We walkedthere so we didn't have to deal with the valet parking. When we left, there were 4 or 5 parties waiting in line for the valetparking pickup so that could be a little annoying, but with limited parking for all the nearby businesses I can see why they aredoing it they way. Read more

We arrived on a Saturday night and were seated , by the huge Window overlooking the Barnstable Harbor. It was beautiful, just as... the sun was setting. Our meals where great and the service was great as well. We look forward to going back. Read more

My husband and I are on our honeymoon & this was one of our favorite spots. Maria, our server, was just fabulous. She was... knowledgeable about the food, drinks, and location! The food was absolutely delicious and came out very fast. The ambiance isgreat- a very east coast harbor feel. We will definitely be back on our next trip to the Cape. Oh, and amazing desserts!!! Wegot the peanut butter pie. The owner makes it! Read more

Went at 3 pm, only served the lunch menu at that time. ( couldn’t order off the dinner menu) A little disappointed because I... was going to order the grilled swordfish. I got the baked swordfish instead, nice portion just a little bland on flavor. Solidclam chowder, Wife got the lobster tacos and loved it. Finished off with peanut butter pie and that was a 10. Service was great,as was the view of the water. We have never been to Barnstable before because we are out of state but would go back again whenvisiting the Cape Read more

We had a great time celebrating our father’s birthday here. Nice ocean view and we all enjoy seeing the boats. Foods were... great and the deserts are delicious ????. Read more

Clam chowder was phenomenal. The lobster roll was generous and fresh. The cod bites were also good. I wasn't in love with the... clams casino nor was I overly impressed with the fish and chips. Wait staff was lovely and the view was great too. They ONLY hadvalet parking which was a little strange but the attendant was very kind and efficient Read more