Reviews for Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering in Bay Shore, NY

My daughter got married here it was amazing staff,food,atmosphere were all on point

Very nice place to eat ???? ????. The atmosphere is nice with a great scenery of Bayshore Marina. Very clean, service is... excellent and friendly staff. The food ???? tastes delicious ????. Whether on a date or out with the family going here you can'tgo wrong. ???????????????? Read more

The food is always excellent!! Service and atmosphere perfect!!! Seafood is always perfectly done. I had seafood platter... pictured below, on this visit hubby had the grouper!! Fantastic!!! Read more

Family wedding took place here and it really was exceptional. The food was as good as I've ever had at a wedding and the service... was extremely friendly. All the staff were available, all the time, and very pleasant. I was impressed with the entireoperation. Read more

Had a Saturday afternoon reservation for party of 12 after a graduation, staff was great at accommodating and was ready for us.... Food was delicious, service was awesome as were the waterviews. If u have room for desserts get one, they won't disappoint! Read more

One of the best places to get married on Long Island or just have a party. Amazing water views. Awesome food. Always friendly... to our team. Working with Berlin is always a pleasure. Thank you for all the great times! Read more

Food was fabulous and fresh! They give you plenty of time to eat and drink. Waitress is excellent at refilling mimosas and... coffee. Chef makes your choice of omelet with lots of items to choose from. Valet parking is great Great view. Making areservation to come back in July!! Highly recommend Read more

Portions were small, and the value was okay for the price. You pay more for the ambiance and the fine dining experience. But... the seafood wasn't bad, and we enjoyed a good time as a group since it had a nice setting. For this reason (the view and finedining experience), we would return. Not necessarily for the food, there are better places we know. The staff and hosts weregreat. Read more