Reviews for Peter Pan Diner in Bay Shore, NY
Very good, I always saw many vehicles outside and it made me curious. The experience was really very good.
I went to the Peter Pan Diner on 8/27/2022. I have always enjoyed the food and service at this diner. I ordered The New Champ... sandwich and everything was great. Shortly after receiving my food, the owner came to my table with another The New Champsandwich. He told me he saw the sandwich as it was being delivered to my table and he noticed the sandwich was not big enough,so he brought me another sandwich to take home. I had no problem with the first sandwich, but it did not measure up to thestandards of the owner. What a surprise! Kindness is always a wonderful thing. Read more
Peter Pan Diner hits!!!! Crazy grilled cheeses, ONION RINGS, and great service. Also, incredible playlist on a late summer... Sunday night. Read more
Love their Hamburgers! Good selection with moderate prices. Great place for eating in, take out or delivery Extremely friendly... owners and personnel. My favorite restaurant in Bay Shore since early eighties. Read more
Delicious waffles and chocolate chip pancakes. The ice coffee was also very good. The staff is so friendly!. Lots of parking !
Great apple cinnamon pancakes. My husband loved the Greek omelet. Coffee was very hot. Just the way I like it. Definitely going... back again! Read more
Waitress and hostess were very warm, courteous and professional. They even remembered my Mom (we just buried her the day before)... who would come a bit with my sister. Love the burgers there, pickles, fries with gravy, dessert, everything! Yum! Highlyrecommended! Read more
No reservations accepted - We had a group of 8 and there was a 20 minute wait to get in. Parking in their lot - spaces are... tight. His & Her restrooms. They have tables, booths & High chairs. Everyone was nice & friendly from servers to management. Weordered coffee, OJ, Apple juice, Pepsi, various omelets, burgers, sandwiches with dip, London broil steaks & various fries - allwere delicious. Kid friendly too. Read more