Reviews for The Penny Pub in Bay Shore, NY
My go to latenight spot for drinks, food and a laid back vibe with friends. Coming here with a good few close ones will do you... good. The bar food is good too. Steak fries, quesadillas, and the wings. The only spot on Main that stay open past 2am on theweekends Read more
Great Pub atmosphere, staff are friendly and pretty fast when place is busy. They are worth a great tip. Pool table in back for... some fun the foods not bad either. Very chill and fun place to go. Read more
Delicious wings and Parmesan Truffle Fries. The bartender Jenny(I think) and the CHEF were on point. Will definitely be back.
Bartenders are quick to judge. Most of all the bouncers think they are police ( blood has been shed) . No longer an Irish pub.... My name is on the wall. Under the current ownership I?m embarrassed I ever frequent the establishment Read more
The bathroom had no hand soap or hand sanitizer the whole time we were there. The food was great but it was finger food and... again no hand soap. So yeah. Outside area is really nice and drinks were good. A little overpriced for what it is but hey Iguess that's ny these days Read more
This is my go-to spot in Bay Shore! The food is absolutely amazing ! They make all their sauces/dressings in house - the... Guinness Gravy and Beer Cheese are beyond delicious! They have wings with a variety of options/spice levels/flavors - includingLemon Pepper, the typical Buffalo, Irish Whisky BBQ, Garlic & Herb, etc. Love them all - but my fav is the Lemon Pepper (eventhough I typically steer clear of anything with pepper as I hate spicy! it's not too peppery, thankfully! more of a dry prep asopposed to saucy like the buffalo. ) The atmosphere is also super relaxed - the bartenders & crowd are always friendly ! Loveit here! Read more
Old school bar, pub food all good. Great drinks, specials and service.
I was just visting NY and it was my first time at this place. I LOVED it! The pumpkin pie martini was amazing as was the food.... Seems like anything on the menu is excellent. Bartender was all smiles and great service! Read more