Reviews for Bayville Deli in Bayville, NY
First visited 5 years ago on business from Georgia. The pizza is phenomenal, and the owner and staff really went above and... beyond to both welcome me and educate me on the area. A dozen visits later I'm still hooked, and I always stop in for a sliceand a soda when I'm on Long Island. Five stars is not enough! Read more
They charge $6 for a slice of pizza. Who charges that much for a slice of mediocre pizza
Good prices, good food. And the people were kind. . .
They're this huge written out sign do not read newspaper unless your going to buy it. Omg what is it a dollar? With all the... business we the locals give you, while we wait can't look at paper and put it back? Also the pizza man said we have nocondiments salt, pepper,garlic powder. Huh that's pennies . Thee owners are super good people I know but please we the smallcommunity give alot. Looking at a paper or asking for salt shouldn't be a problem for a deli. Thank u Read more
Walked in. Waited at the counter for 10 minutes. Not one person came out from the back. I live in Bayville and will not be going... back there. There are plenty of other deli's in Bayville to choose from. In this day of small businesses losing so much, theyshould be taking care of the customers they do have. THUMBS DOWN! Read more
My favorite deli in Bayville. Staff is wonderful and make you feel at home. They have great food and serve eggs all day. Pizza... is excellent as well. Read more
I must come here about once a week for my regular order, an American Classic Pie with Extra Chicken and Extra Russian on the... Side, and I am always the most happy and satisfied. I love the guys there, and will always be coming. Thanks as always,Mitchell. Read more
Nice little store , very friendly .Nice place for staples. ( food silly )