Reviews for Cantafio's Buckhorn Steakhouse in Beaver Dam, WI
My husband and I LOVE Supperclubs..We both had the steak sandwiches with fries..mine medium, his well done they were perfect. I... paired mine with mushrooms & onions and he had the soup, potato ham and bacon..Everybody was Friendly..great visit.. Read more
I haven't been here for a couple years so we went recently in the middle of the week. The place hasn't changed inside much. I... ordered chicken which had a salad and baked potato and my wife had fish. The salad was just some lettuce with 2 cherry tomatoesat least we had a choice of dressings. The potato came with no sour cream nor were we asked if we wanted any. Wife got no tartarsauce for the fish also. We ran out of water a couple times also. People were friendly and that's about it. Will I go back,probably not. Just my honest response. Read more
Steak that wee asked for Medium Well was Rare... I don't eat steak that's still mooing... Busy place, if you like meat that's... done rare, you'll probably really enjoy it. Staff is very nice which is why I'm giving it two stars & the drinks were verygood, even got an ice cream drink after- best part of the meal and thankful my daughter was able to get one without alcohol eventhough it wasn't on the menu. So why I deducted stars, which is really difficult for me from here because family know them andthey are wonderful people who had a tragic loss of their son in the military.... -Bathroom had leftovers in it (bartender madethe comment that it was probably from last night, first thing my sister in law asked me was, didn't they clean it?). So had toremove a star for that. Also Removed one because all of us but two were given rare steaks. Even those that prefer medium said itwas under done for their liking and my center was still cold- I didn't eat the rest of it there after I figured that out, justbrought it home to finish cooking it. Personally was not my favorite place to eat, I wouldn't go back. Thought it was VERYpricy, not seasoned well. My in-laws were happy with their meals- their steaks were cooked as asked, or a little under done, butnot as under done as the rest of ours. So the cost makes me want to deduct another start, but I'm not sure that's enough reasonto. Just to compare though- We go out to super clubs often in Green Bay and it was at least an extra $10 a plate compared towhat we just paid in Green Bay (mind you my 32 ounce steak, double salad bar trips and double potatoes option that I got at outo town cost the same as the 6-8 ounce steak here 2 weeks apart). The drinks I thought were better at Cantafios & the bartenderwas great when he remade a drink that didn't taste quite right at no extra charge. Feel like it was heavy on the pour as well incomparison. Read more
Hands down the BEST eatery in Beaver Dam! The service was simply outstanding. Very warm, welcoming and friendly and you never... had an empty drink on your table. Even more, the food was phenomenal. The Buckhorn Tradition - a deep fried onion with chipotlesauce, was huge! The steak was perfectly cooked and hit the spot, too. Altogether, everything was fresh and hot. One of myfavorite aspects, however, was the beautiful homage to the owners fallen veteran son. Bringing his story into their restaurantprovided a touching aspect to my visit. Kudos to the owners for providing free meals to veterans, too. The owners, along withthe staff, truly put their heart and soul into this steakhouse. It is immaculately clean and provides a wonderful atmosphere fora dinner out. My husband and I would happily make the drive from Appleton to return. Highly, highly recommend - it's worth thestop! Read more
Steak was very good. They're very veteran friendly. If your a vet you get to eat for free.
This was our first time here. It is a traditional supper club. The food was good the service was great day the ice cream drinks... were good. You get alot of food for a fair price. In Milwaukee you would pay 75.00 or more for the prime rib that was 36.00here. Read more
Had the Big Ben prime rib with baked potatoes and onions block appetizer. Was seated right away and then server took my drink... order. She was very pleasant and professional. The food was very tasty. I also received a bread stick basket with cheesespread and a roll. The roll wasl the only thing that did not stand out. Also had the clam chowder. Read more
A classic family favorite. Had a great brandy old fashioned and a killer ribeye. One of my favorite Wisconsin supper clubs. Good... service, friendly smiles, and I love the cheese dip on the table. Will be back. Read more