Reviews for Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta Italian Restaurant in Bedminster, NJ

I spent almost $40 on a lunch and when I asked for a glass of water they told me "we don't do that," and tried to sell me... bottled water. Couldn't just fill a cup from the stack on the host stand with free tap water and give it to me? Unreal. Read more

stopped by here yesterday afternoon based on a decent experience in the past, Not so much this time. Ordered two dinners,... chicken franchaise and chicken Parmesan, as well as order of mozzarella sticks. The chicken franchaise was extremely tough,edible but not enjoyable, and severely lacking in flavor. Mozzarella sticks were completely under cooked. Almost $60 later, onedecent meal out of the entire order. Read more

We frequently stop for a slice for a quicky meal. Outstanding choices. Also love the chicken brochetta pizza. Have dined in... occasionally. Good all around. Read more

The pizza here is consistently good!! Oh and they use fresh jalapeños instead of the canned version which makes a world of a... difference if you want to kick it up a notch. The eggplant parm sammy is also great. Read more

One of the best slices I’ve ever tried. And this coming from a New Yorker. Everything down to the sauce was perfect! Customer... service was also great :) Read more

Absolutely brutal! There are much better frozen pizza options in the grocery store. They literally add zero cheese and their... cheestake is beyond dry. They actually make you feel like they are doing me a favor when ordering One time I bought a pound ortwo of chicken wings and there were three left on the plate and the woman actually put them back in display to sell. Done withthat place for good Read more

Great for a large variety of slices all day.

This place is crazy expensive and rarely gets the order right. This cheese steak has no meat! The reason it gets 2 stars is the... woman who works the counter is always nice. Read more