Reviews for Fat Boy's Pizza and Ice Cream in Bellefontaine, OH

Too expensive , when I called for a pan pizza it was a thin pizza on the bottom , really ? Won't order again , 25 dollars for a... pepperoni pizza , ridiculous Read more

Best pizza in town ,can't wait to go back.

New to the area and had the opportunity to try a couple other locations for their pizza. I have to say, having only tried Fat... Boys once, they have the best pies in town! Amazing! Read more

Pizza is ok. We like the flavor...we always get extra cheese. I wish they would put the cheese on top. Can not even see the... regular cheese on it let alone extra cheese. Plus the topping fall off. Some may like this but we sure don't. Read more

We were passing through town and i heard Fat boys Pizza was pretty good! I called and ordered a double pepporoni add sausage... pizza. My wife and I started eating it on the way home. We both said "wow! This is good! We'll be back for sure! Thanks guys! Read more

We love this pizza place. Pizza is so good and they have a convenient drive thru window! Thin crust is a amazing and the sweet... sauce is everything you want in a pizza sauce! Read more

They had a nice and clean facility. The service was good. We got there right after opening and got our food pretty quick just... had to wait for the fryer to heat up! Read more

This is by far the best pizza in Logan County! Every pizza that I have received from Fat Boy's has been phenomenal but I love... the Big Daddy best. Try it, you will not be disappointed at all. Read more