Reviews for Paoli Schoolhouse American Bistro in Belleville, WI

This was a completely unexpected joy. The food - we went at brunch - was amazing. I don't usually enjoy butternut squash, but I... had their autumn harvest salad and it was delightful and the french toast spread my partner enjoyed had my mouth watering. Asingle drink is more than enough here, as their bartenders really know how to pour drinks! My only complaint, however, is thatfor the amount we paid and the appearance of the restaurant, the service was far below my expectations. The server we had didhis best and was very delightful, but even for a busier time of day, it took quite a long time for a server to come to our tableinitially. We had reservations, and I hoped a server would at least come to tell us they would be right with us, but that didn'thappen until we were about ready to ask for one. I'm sure it wasn't his fault, but I'd have liked to see better communicationbetween the wait staff and hosts. Other than that, I'd say this one is definitely a spot we'll come back to! Read more

The best restaurant in Madison, except it's in Paoli. Perfect farm to table food, amazing service, historic building, and live... music outside. My new #1 in Madison (Paoli is close enough!) Read more

A friend and I did an overnight trip to Paoli from Chicago. The community is so picturesque and this schoolhouse bistro... definitely added to the charm. The interior was beautiful. It was light and airy and felt casually elegant. We sat outsideon the porch because my friend brought her pooch. They accommodated the dog with a bowl of water. Although we only had salads,they were fresh and delicious with light and flavorful homemade dressings. The staff was so friendly. It was a pleasant placeto have lunch. Read more

We met our daughter and family here for brunch and we were delighted. It was a beautiful day and we enjoyed the patio. They are... on the top of their game with presentation of each dish, friendliness of the staff, and variety of the menu. The mushroom patewas superb. We had the added bonus of the Sunday farmer?s market with live music and browsing the shops down the street. Tocomplete the day, strawberry picking is about 5 miles away. The area is truly worth a visit starting with a stop at theSchoolhouse Bistro. Read more

Just had dinner at this amazing restaurant. The mussels appetizer and Beef Wellington is some of the best I have ever had. Lois... our server was very friendly, attentive, responsive and knowledgeable about the menu. Atmosphere is really great. One of my bestdining experiences. Read more

An incredible find for us on a bike ride south from Madison on the Badger State Trail. It's just 3 minutes off the trail by... bike. We went for brunch and everything was excellent. The owner so personable as well. Read more

What an excellent find just outside of Verona! Farm to table in a wonderfully redone school house, this is a fantastic place for... an upscale dinner out. This quaint town is so inviting. Visit for live music or a shopping trip, but be sure to dine here whenyou do. Indoor and outdoor seating available. Friendly service and they do take reservations. Don't miss it! Read more

Oh my goodness!! There are not words in the English language to describe how amazing this place is! The service is phenomenal; a... server is always available, but not constantly interrupting. The food is delectable. It is so good. You think it's going to bean ordinary brunch, but one bite and you are blown away!! The flavors are.....it's like a party in your mouth! The portion sizesare large. My family walked away very satisfied! Our compliments to the chef and all the staff that make Paoli Schoolhouse afabulous experience. Read more