Reviews for Jackie Reilly's in Bethpage, NY
Nice old school Irish pub. Think NYC irish pub. Reason for 3 stars is i ordered food off the website menu (great wings btw) and... all the prices were different when I picked up my order? Perhaps they need to update their website prices. Alittle pricey forthe food. The wings were great everything else was so so. Spent over 50dollars for 3 appetizers. Seems like a bit much but I'dreturn for the wings. Read more
Popped in today with My Great Friend Noel!! Sean Reilly and Jen the Bartender has been helping us out for over 25 yrs. The... best!!!! Read more
We were here for a birthday party. Just stayed & chatted for a few minutes. Wine served was OK. Wait staff very nice &... accommodating. Read more
I had fish and chips which were both cooked to crunchy perfection. The owner personally came to talk with us and he is the best.... Service was awesome. Read more
My friend and I had the steak salad. The both of us said the same thing, way too salty!! My boyfriend ordered the fried fish, ... Horrible !! Drinks were warm. Fries were best part of meal Read more
I have gone there many times in the past, but not since the pandemic. Only one friend of mine is able to go w me usually. But... it is a wonderful, welcoming Irish pub style/ restaurant! They have a great assortment of chicken, steak and pork dishes, but myfriend and I always enjoyed their Shepherds pie the best! It is freshly made with delicious mashed potatoes on top. Thewaitresses are Irish, and very helpful and friendly in an atmosphere of rustic wood and music in the background. There isentertainment every Friday night w warm, friendly dining all the time ???????????? I highly recommend it for an enjoyableexperience!????????? Read more
I lived in Seaford, I went there every weekend .Loved it than and still do ,I live in Virginia beach now for the past 6 years,... But everytime I come back to visit family ,I stop in to have my favorite Beer,And the best onion soup and The most deliciousShepherd pie,The owner is such a sweetheart, He makes you feel at home ,Always comes over to say hi and welcomes you,I mean who does that anymore,Its a beautiful safe fun place to go. The workers are the kindest ? pleasant people you will ever meet. Lovethe live bands,The Best Irish bar and food in the neighborhood,God Bless,I will always come back home to go to my secondhome.They make you feel like family.And that's how I think of them.Thank you all and God Bless you all. 10 stars from me and myfamily.The Stratton family ? Read more
Ordered a cpl drink n apps. My drink tasted like watered down Bacardi n coke n the food was soo over cooked. We sent the chicken... tenders back and I ate my potato skins just bc I was starving, they were not very gd tho. They seem to be understaffed bc ourwaitress was constantly on the go n wasnt able to give each table the attention each deserved. The inside is nice n clean. Read more