Reviews for Island Pizza Company in Big Pine Key, FL
This Oct 27, Thursday I place order on line because no one answered the phone but that?s nothing new for this business. So put... order on line. The order was excepted and confirmed and said that pick up would be @ 6:50. We?ll door was locked and sign ondoor. Giving employees day off.. Credit card was charged. REALLY About 3 months ago ordered and went to pick up and doorlocked said they were out of dough. This business is so unreliable very poor. Rating -0. Oct 27 was Thursday not the weekend sowhat?s that got to do with the weekend? Yes you were closed on 10/27/22 and but my credit card was still charged for 17.44 receipt # S462300798027221 I have not seen a refund as of yet. Read more
Can?t handle more than a few orders at a time. Good pizza but horrible service. Give me a price I?ll buy it and show you how... to make pizza and money Read more
Great meat lovers pizza. Dough is fresh. There is almost a sweetness to it. A large feeds 2 people easily. Bread sticks are... something to marvel with the garlic and butter dancing in your mouth. Read more
Pretty good pizza, but they never answer the phone and they stop online orders. We?ve tried several times since moving... here?gets frustrating. Read more
Simply Terrible. Rarely open, new owners have no clue. Was the best spot in BPK for a quick lunch. No longer. Pizza is... just not the same, sauce tasted rancid and feels like a couple purple haired hippies running the place. Will be gone byseason. Hopefully next owners will be more like Popa Jims and not two kids playing restaurant owner for fun. Read more
Pizza is excellent. Staff was pleasant and accommodating. My opinion is the new owners are doing an excellent job and deserve... the communities support. Read more
Just picked up pizza with bacon and sausage, which the owner delivered right to our car. He was very nice and personable so I... don't understand why others gave such negative reviews. Anyway, this was one of the best pizzas we've ever had and will orderagain! Read more
We ordered the veggie pizza tonight and it was The Absolute Best!! It tasted so fresh and was Perfection. Owners are so nice.... Service is fast. Definitely going back! Read more