Reviews for Benny's Off the Water in Birdseye, IN
We recently had a family wedding at the Patoka Lake Winery and hired Benny?s Off the Water to do the catering for both the... rehearsal dinner and the wedding, and we could not be happier with our decision. The menu selection was extensive for bothevents, and the food was outstanding! It was a pleasure working with Marty as he was not only professional and personable, buthis culinary expertise was outstanding. We highly recommend this unexpected catering treasure. Read more
We come here every time we camp at patoka lake and we have a great time! The staff is great, the atmosphere is kid friendly, and... the food is great! We will be back next year. Read more
The Brisket was out of this world! Everyone else else in the party loved what they had as well; salads, pizza, fish sandwich,... pulled pork, and hot wings! All AMAZING!! Read more
Cold beer and great food. We really enjoyed it. The pizza and breadsticks were delicious. We will be back again this weekend.... Dog friendly too. Read more
Received a Big T's pulled pork sandwich which was given to me twice under cooked and on top of that, got me sick. Hard pass on... this spot as most of there food I tried was frozen and not freshly cooked... Read more
Stopped there for lunch today. Great food and service! I had the brisket sandwich and I was not disappointed! BBQ sauce was good... but I can buy Sweet Baby Rays at the store. Onion rings also did not disappoint, quite yummy. Everyone else really enjoyed theirfood too. Great stop on a Jeepin? road trip! Read more
Had heard their pizza was good, but was pleased to find it was superb! Crust was not too thick or thin; edge was just a touch... crispy while rest of crust was delightfully chewy. They are generous with the cheese and toppings. Everything was just perfect!They have a nice kids menu and lots of sandwich, appetizer, salad and beer options. A lovely gem in an out-of-the-way locale.Well worth a drive. Serve was excellent, too, even though they were rocking a half hour before closing! Read more
We stopped in for dinner after being on the lake all day. Food was good and the portions were large. We were there at least an... hour before the kitchen closed, but everyone was busy trying to close for the night. Our waitress was nice but we had to keepflagging her down for drink refills. Most of the time we had at least 5 servers standing around talking about their plans toparty when the customers finally left. We were also lucky enough to hear a story about another one of them who "vomited all overthe place" the last time they all partied together. So glad my family and I were able to hear all about that while we wereeating.....Looking forward to a 5 star visit next time Read more