Reviews for The Horse and Sulky Pub & Grill in Bloomingburg, NY

Never disappointed yet...had Grandma D's Meatloaf.....OMG delicious and the loaded potato soup was a homerun for me....I'm a... food critic and loved every dish I had here....kudos to the chef Read more

Great pub we found! Bartender was so nice and friendly and the food was delicious!

Great food & drinks. Prices are modest for the amount of food you get. I will go here as a regular stop when in the area. The... staff was very friendly and helpful. Read more

The food was great but they had musicians who were way too loud. We asked to have them lower the music but were ignored. ... Many of the patrons left because of how uncomfortable the level of the music was. Please have Dave discuss with themusicians. Read more

The food is horrible. Your menu said crispy wings, they are not. They are under cooked. The parm trio was the worse, the... eggplant was definitely not eggplant it was leather. The chicken was very dry. I'm honestly baffled by how gross the food is.Will never be back. The bartender was very nice. The building is very pretty. We could not eat the trio and they still madeus pay for it!!! Unreal. The worst 50 dollar lunch of my life. Read more

We sat at the bar for drinks and appetizers. All the staff was very accommodating and friendly. Nice beverage selection and food... was exactly as requested. Can't wait to go back and try more! Read more

I?d like to give this place a higher rating because the food is really good and inexpensive. However, they never have enough... cooks and wait staff. My husband and I walked in on a Saturday, got seated and then we were told it would take an hour for thefood to come. Sorry, but we walked right out. It is best to come here on a weeknight. But even then we?ve waited for our foodfor a while. And never seems to be enough cooks. I wouldn?t mind waiting, but they don?t have anything on the table like breadOr chips or anything to nosh on in the meantime. So, if you?re really hungry this is not the place to come. They do not evenoffer you an alternative. Other than that, everyone is so polite and as I said when you do get your food it is delicious. Read more

Best Pulled Pork Mac and cheese, so yummy delicious. Thei caramel apple martini was on point. Definitely going back. Thank you... to the amazing staff. Read more