Reviews for Tobin's Pizza in Bloomington, IL

Bill Whisenant 1 year ago

Just had my 1st ever pizza from here. It was actually pretty screwed up, half thin crust and half thick. Was told 30 minutes and... it was probably ready in 10 or 15. Aside from those issues it's still a solid 5 stars. Plenty of toppings and everything wasfresh, as business traveler this is the best pizza i have had away from home in years! If i enjoyed this one, i can't wait toget one made correctly! Read more

Thomas 1 year ago

Tobin's used to be great but the last two visits have been very sub-par. If this trend keeps up, we may stop going for a while. ... Ordered a giant size mama Theresa's pizza with extra tomato and the order taker on the phone was so rushed he got it wrong. Hardly any tomatoes. Boo!!! Read more

Ron T 1 year ago

Pan pizza was excellent. Excellent service. You can tell the owner cares about the place. The side salad was mediocre. Needs... more ingredients. Read more

Rochelle Bustamante 1 year ago

Wings and pizza were very good. Overall, great service.

Samantha Ballinger 1 year ago

Love the pizza from Tobin's. The eat-in atmosphere is old school and fun, a nice change of pace. Their family bunch stretcher... is a great deal that allows for extra pizza you can eat the next day! Read more

Local Guy 21 1 year ago

We decided to order some Micheleo?s tonight since it had been awhile and we are so glad we did! The pizza was awesome and... perfectly cooked! The family buck stretcher with an extra small pizza and 4 drink deal and a small side a bbq sauce made itperfect! The delivery also arrived quickly so we were very pleased! If your hungry for pizza you need to give them a call! Read more

Calvin Parker Jr. 2 years ago

This place is Incredible! From the crispy undercarriage to the plentiful toppings it is seriously some of the best pizza I've... had in my life. I drive 27 miles just for this pizza. I highly recommend the pork lovers family size where you get a small fora 1$! Party!! Read more

Emme C 3 years ago

I?ve been saying since I moved here I?d try it for dinner. I finally did and I will say I waited 2 years too long. It?s nice, I... bet being served in-house would be greater and maybe once most of the COVID restrictions disappear I can enjoy a nice pizza piefrom here seated. My family tried a large half pepperoni half cheese, thin crust. I appreciate how the sauce didn?t have a weirdsweet after-taste like some others in town we have tried. The pizza was warm when delivered and the packaging looked neat. Ialso had a half order of the fried mushrooms which came with ranch. I really really applaud them for poking holes in the cartonso the mushrooms weren?t soggy by the time the reached us. Next time I will try another side and come back to review. Read more