Reviews for J T's On the Bay in Blue Point, NY
There are two aspects to the experience. The lunch scene is chill and expensive($140 for 2 with tip). Night with music is great.... Worst slaw ever, nice servers. Read more
The outside atmosphere is really fantastic, especially on a nice summer evening. The food was incredible. Best baked clams I?ve... had anywhere before, and the sea scallops were incredible (especially the cauliflower purée and little salad that it comeswith). Only reason it?s getting 4 instead of 5 stars is I wish the portions were a little bit better, was only served 5 scallopsand was still pretty hungry afterwards. I also tasted a bit of the Mahi Mahi that my mom had on her plate and that was excellenttoo. Will come again and will reccomend to others! Read more
if you enjoy over paying for truly subpar food this is your place to dine. yesterday, july 26th, four of us went here for lunch.... my friend & i both had the beer battered cod sandwich. both sandwiches came with 2 pitifully small pieces of cod. his came witha spring mix salad. there was nothing on the greens, no tomato no onion nada. i asked for the Mediterranean orzo. it came in ahalf full 2 ounce paper cup. that was a blessing as the orzo was mush. my wife ordered a fried flounder sandwich. it was ananemic inetible , what seemed like a frozen piece of fish. she also had the orzo salad. lastly my friend's wife had field greenswith grilled chicken. she liked the chicken but not the greens. we had calamari appetizer which was worth having. we each had 1cocktail apiece. the bill w/o tip came to just over $168.00! service was good. unless you have to i would definitely pass onJT's. Read more
We had the salmon Cesar salad and south shore Cobb salad. Both were delicious. Service from the servers is very good and bar... staff service is also very good. The view is worth the trip to sit out on a beautiful sunny summer day. Read more
This place was underwhelming and disappointing. Granted they were busy but at the bar it shouldn't be 45mins just to be greeted.... We ordered as soon as the extremely nice bartender greeted us (the only positive) and it took another hour for food to arrive.We ordered fish tacos and mussels. The fish was cooked to the point that it was charred black, it was dry and hard as a rock.Mussels were not good as most shells were closed, and sauce was the wrong type. Will not be back. Read more
So delicious fresh seafood on the water one of my favorite summer spots. Boats even come up to the dock to pick up takeout.... Parking is a bit hard but it's worth it. Read more
If you are interested in having a beautiful meal on a beautiful day, try the Black Sea Bass with a lemon fennel risotto and a... brocollini surprise addition. Fabulous flavors, seasoned perfectly and well balanced. Get it while you can! Read more
Where do I begin?!? Ohmygosh...I LOVE THIS LITTLE GEM! Sadly I only recently was introduced to JT's...but I've been there 3... times in the past 2 weeks, going today, Sunday, 9/4, and getting together with friends on Labor Day to have a last fling for theseason...their closing for the season tomorrow. :( Great staff, excellent eats, drinks, atmosphere... I'll miss this littleplace when we move to GA. But I am introducing JT's to my friends today, and tomorrow...2 will be missing, many will take ourplaces. Thanks for the wonderful memories guys. ?? Read more