Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Bohemia, NY

Always a great experience when we come here! Tonight was the busiest we’ve seen it since pre- Covid. Staff was awesome and all... customers were attended to promptly. Would definitely recommend to anyone from dining alone to bringing the whole family! We satat the bar, Ashley is always fantastic! Read more

I gotta say this has become our family's favorite Pizza spot.... coal fire!!!! That's exactly what caught my eye, it makes such... a big difference in taste....this place is supper cute! dim light, modern, relaxing, cool, chill vibe...never falls short! Frompizza to garlic knots, chicken wings, Sandwiches, all the way to dessert... Great Americanos, amazing tiramisu and cheesecake! Prices are great you can never go wrong on anything on their menu. Read more

Was in the area for business. Came in during happy hour and sat at the bar. Bartender was extremely nice. Sent some free wing... samples my way. Good food. Outstanding service. Read more

Great place! A lot of surprise toppings really can't go wrong with the pizza. Well made worth a visit

Just had dinner at anthony’s last night. our server ally was great. She let us know that the ribs were back which we missed.... She also had us sign up for the loyalty program. They even have pumpkin beer on tap already! Great food and service !! Read more

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had was at their location in Bohemia, Long Island. Ingredient are fresh and delicious. We... ate here twice in two days. Try Martha’s meatballs also. Great stuff. Service was wonderful. Read more

It's a nice place but could rate higher with a little effort. The staff was great... Busboy was on top of everything, waitress... was very pleasant and accommodating. The wings, kinda of a surprise... The original were excellent and done different than weare use to... With caramelized onions and maybe roasted... Very good... The dry rub ones were good as well. The pizza... 2different kinds... One with a gluten free crust and the other smothered in different meat... Both very good. Where it became aonly a three star experience unfortunately was in how clean it appeared... Tables shouldn't be left with sticky residue...Shouldn't be old dried food stuck to various things ( the pizza tray holders ). I kinda want to put this one on management...Didn't see a manger around and a team needs leadership... He/She would be pointing things out like a tables that needed moreattention to detail. I'd go back for another try... But that might be about it if the tables look and feel the same and nothingchanges... Hope it was just an off night because everything else was pretty solid. Read more

I like the chicken wings and meatballs from this restaurant. The beef meatballs are so tender and tasty, and my son loves it. I... love the chicken wings which are soft and tasty too! Other food like pizza are great too! Only one comment: Why not serve pastawith meatballs? Read more