Reviews for Yellow Cottage Deli & Bakery in Branchville, NJ
Went there today 9/9/22- Asked for a Caesar chicken salad and paid extra for avocados. The salad was made with plain lettuce. 3... cube size pieces of avocado and 5 tiny pcs of chicken. No Parmesan cheese. It was so plain my 6 year old could have made it.Horrible salad. Literally plain lettuce with 1/2? size of chicken (5 pcs). Got Half Turkey sub and the bread was so dry. Gotcup cake for my husband. It was probably 1 week old. Bad bad bad experience. Won?t be back ???? Read more
Update: Tried giving this business a second chance 2 years later and she?s still as nasty as ever. She actually hung up on me... when I was going to place a cake order. NEVER again!! The brown derby cake is good but the woman there is beyond rude. I wastrying to support a local business but I would rather take my business elsewhere. This lady needs to learn manners. Read more
Friendly staff and great bakery selection. I read some reviews of people saying they have ?big city prices??? when was the last... time you went to the city??? Yellow cottage is reasonably priced and overall great selection. Read more
Great bakery products. Old style hard rolls. Excellent cannolis, chocolate eclairs, pies and cakes. Not always open as hours on... door state. Read more
Place is Alright, Staff was very friendly and Italian Sub was very good. Nice selection of homestyle soda. Disappointed in my... cheesesteak though. Beef was rancid tasting and was all uniformly cut like it came out of a box or something. Sandwich bread wasmush by the time I unwrapped it. Seemed expensive for something that didn't taste right. Read more
The BEST pastries around! Always well worth the drive! Definitely recommend the Napoleans, Chocolate Eclairs, Canolis, and... bakery cookies. They have many other items to offer (not just desserts!) too including made-to-order sandwiches, pasta salads,and more! You're missing out if you don't stop here! Read more
Stumbled upon this place while driving back to New York. Very friendly staff and homey atmosphere. Ordered the bacon/egg/cheese... sandwich and a ham sandwich with potato salad. Both were delicious and fresh! Almond croissants was very good with real almondpaste. Best part they had a bear cookie ???? Read more
Big delishous sandwiches and good coffee! They also have variety of pastries. We stayed in Cobmin Ridge Motel right across the... deli and it was very convenient for us. By the way the motel is the treasure- rooms are beautiful, unique and functional. Hugesmart TV's. The deli was recommended by my friends who stayed at the motel in the past and I would agree- sandwiches and dessertare really good. I did not try every dessert yet though, but they all look good! Read more