Reviews for Eveready Diner in Brewster, NY
This place could use a good cleaning. The table where I sat was a little gross and I don't usually say that about a restaurant.... I didn't want to lean against the table at all and honestly if not for the fact that my husband is so easygoing, I would haveleft. The food was so mediocre, that I ended up leaving it behind. I took one bite out of my greasy grilled cheese and had acouple of my overcooked sweet potato fries and was done. Read more
We went here because we loved the Eveready Diner that closed up in Hyde Park! Wish we didn't! Can't blame being under-staffed... for the horrible experience as 11 employees stood upfront talking and twiddling their thumbs. The place was filthy! The chairsand bench were covered in food and grease. The host who sat us did come back out with the rag and clean it off, after I hadasked him to. The tables all around us have not been cleared off after other customers have left, even before we got there.Literally 4 tables around us were covered with plates and old food and it was just disgusting. There were flies everywhere. Thefloor was so sticky and covered with food as well. The waitress was nice but VERY forgetful. Never asked us if we wanted drinks,never gave us menus after asking, had to ask twice for coffee. Waited 20 mins for our check.. the waitress never came back. Hadto get the check from the manager. The food was not that great at all either. The chinese salad had wilted black slimy lettucethat tasted like dirt and the burger tasted like a rubber shoe. I feel horrible writing this review because everybody was veryfriendly and nice, but you guys have to do better! Read more
Service is amazing and quick. I got the Red Velvet chocolate chip pancake which were so delicious! I always come here and I... enjoy it every single time. Read more
Our go to diner whenever we?re in the area. Good amounts of convenient parking. Wait staff can be spotty though. Some are good... while others are neglectful and do things like seat you next to the restrooms in an near empty diner. Some of the dishes areoutstanding like the fried chicken, fries and pasta meals. Chocolate cake is outstanding also. The only thing I?ve ever hatedwas their pot pie. Chef has a weird take on pot pie?looks and taste like an over salted plate of vomit. Read more
I was very disappointed with the outcome of my order this evening. I am retired food industry worker who has worked at all... levels of the industry. So i am heartbroken to see the decline in service, quality and acknowledgment of poor food preparationand delivery. I ordered a BLT and had to remove the lettuce. The lettuce is supposed to be the last thing you add to thesandwich and should not be wilted and brown. I took chance and ordered the seafood antipasto. The lesson is mine to learn. Theseafood was covered in a opaque film. The shrimp did taste okay- but the scallops were definitely not good- they had a distinct? foul? odor and sour taste- i did not venture past and had to throw out the entire salad. I also ordered mac and cheese bitesand received a side of mac and cheese instead. Oh well i though people make mistakes- but again i tased it and so did myhusband( as i thought i was going crazy) the cheese tasted rancid. Maybe they use a three cheese approach- but it still shouldnot taste that way. Thew the whole thing out again. Overall the only good part was my husbands burger was awesome and he enjoyedit very much. Sufficed to say i spent of over 60.00 dollars for a meal for my family- wasted most of it, but lessonlearned. Unfortunately i will never order from this establishment in the future. I did call to share my experience: and althoughthe young woman was apologetic; she seemed indifferent. Read more
Excellent orange juice, possibly the best I've ever had. Eggs Benedict was cooked perfectly to my taste. The frittered French... toast looked delightful and my daughter said the waffles were amazing. Read more
Red velvet chocolate chip pancakes are an absolute must. Tasted like cake for breakfast. Good burger and chicken and waffles. A... lot of chicken with the waffle and the chicken was bone in fyi. Good prices and friendly staff. Would come back. Just think theyshould make the chicken boneless with the waffle because you have to pick the chicken off the bone to eat it with the wafflewhich is a little bit of an inconvenience but the chicken was cooked very well and tasted crunchy which paired good with thesoft waffle. Read more
I believe in giving credit where credit is due I'm an over the road truck driver and this is one of the best breakfasts I've had... in a very long time. Not only was the food hot when it arrived to me but it was good and actual good meal on a hard road that Irarely get. thank you for the to the kitchen staff and the people who prepared it and thank you for sending utensils withouthaving to be asked. Read more