Reviews for American Pie in Bridgehampton, NY
Great food, great pizza great service. Can?t wait to go back.
Some of the best pizza on the East End. Crust is perfectly crispy but not too thin. Sauce is wonderful, not too sweet. Great... service, too. Casual, simple environment with a TV on the wall usually showing sports. Read more
Hefty kid gave me back my change folded and palm down. Thought that was odd. Gave spare change as a tip anyway. Only after I... left I realized I was shorted a $10. He must have guessed correctly that I'm not the type for confrontation. Sad because I wentthere to save money compared to going to panera, and ended up paying more. Read more
Their pizza is good, apps are good. Staff is friendly. But the last 4 times they've messed something up with my order.... Cheesesteak with no mushrooms, loaded with mushrooms. Half mushroom pie, half pepperoni, I get half plain. I just wish I couldorder confidently but they keep messing something up. I'm a year round local and order here all the time, thinking they're boundto get my order right. But it just keeps happening. Read more
The food here is soooooo goooood! I think I've actually tried just about everything on the menu...wraps (there's one with bacon... that is so yummy) , soups (best minestrone I've had), pasta (can't decide which one is my favorite), paninis (the veggie one isso delish), pizza (I've had so many kinds and they are all so good-I especially love the crispy crust)! I highly recommendedthis place if you are in the area! Read more
My wife and I have gotten food from here often and every time it has been excellent. They offer a great selection of specialty... slices. My personal favorite is the sausage and peppers slice. They also have great pasta dishes and their paninis remind me ofItaly. There are a lot of pizza places on Long Island but American Pie stands out. Definitely stop in if you?re on the east end. Read more
This place is incredible and the staff is very delightful. I was stuffed after the Stromboli but the pizza was very delicious... for my long drive home. If your ever in the Bridgehampton Area this is the place to stop. The prices are fair and you will notbe disappointed. I will return for a few more slices. Read more
Rude staff. Rude comments about customers. Rolling of the eyes. Always in their cell phones. Highly disappointed