Reviews for Old Man Rafferty’s in Hillsborough Township, NJ
My beef rib was DELICIOUS! better than my husband's steak. Serving sizes are great but the service was really slow. It was... really busy but 30 minutes to get a salad is ridiculous. The table of 6 next to us got there food right before us and they camein 20 minutes after us. All in all I will return. They have a vast menu and I want to try other things. Read more
Interesting restaurant. The food we ordered was classic American..burger and nachos, which seemed to be a mismatch to the... atmosphere...not a bad thing, just Interesting. We liked out food and the menu was diverse. Atmosphere was nice and relaxing. Weenjoyed our visit and would recommed. Read more
Used to be one of our favorite restaurants when we lived in the area years ago. Now that we are back, there is a good chance it... will be again. The new menu has some wonderful items, the always spectacular deserts are even more amazing as individual cakesand our dinner was fantastic. Servers were beyond attentive!!! Thanks for making it a great anniversary dinner! Read more
UPD: We ordered burgers again today and i am changing my rating to 4 star. The food was excellent, definitely the best burgers... in the area. Also they changed their containers for burger toppings to clear plastic which makes it easier to check thequality. Got a moldy tomatoes with one of the burgers, looks like quality control issue. Good thing i looked at it beforeputting it on the burger. The burgers were good though, i wish i could give them a better rating. Read more
For lunch had the seared Ahi Tuna in greens salad that was fresh and tasty, a few craft beers, and nice chat with the bartender.... Quite a spacious place and an attractive outdoor seating area. Conversations between servers and patrons leads me to believethis is a favorite place for the locals. Only ask, if they haven't explored already, offer a larger variety of craft beersespecially from local breweries. Read more
Large yet cozy decor. Dining area on one side the bar on the other with large outdoor dining area available from the time of the... pandemic. The Cosmo cocktail inspired a Fig Cosmo, was good but a slightly too sweet for me. The Best of the Wurst was verysolid, the sautéed apple slices mixed with the beetroot and cabbage were an excellent garnish. The ahi tuna salad was amazing.A generous portion with wide variety of greens, including green beans and the dressing made the tuna just right. The ahi tunawas seared just right, pink on the inside, slightly smoky with sesame seeds on the outside. Uncommon food for a seemingly commonbar restaurant. Bravo. Read more
Great local business with ties to the community. The food is great with a well thought out menu, and the people are awesome. ... Our waitress Rachel was amazing, never wrote down a thing but got our order perfect. Will continue to come back again andagain. Read more
Attended a 50th birthday party here last night. The staff were all very attentive and helpful, especially our server Lauren. She... was absolutely amazing with a party of 25 people. She was on top of everyone's needs, provided suggestions for guests that wereunsure about what meals to get, and was a pro at directing where meals were going as they came out. She was so good that one ofthe kids was asking where she was to make sure she could say goodbye before leaving. Food was excellent, atmosphere waswelcoming, and we will definitely be returning in the future. Read more