Reviews for Coney I-Lander in Broken Arrow, OK
The coneys were good, but the menu states they come with mustard & they didn?t. I would have requested mustard if I?d known.... Alone, this would be ok;however, I ordered a frito pie & the Fritos were completely stale & ruined the meal. My husbandrequested a large 3-way, and I requested a small Frito pie, but they were the exact same size. Also, his was covered in onionsafter we requested no onions. Basically nothing we ordered was correct. These things individually wouldn?t be a problem, butall in one meal left a bad taste in our mouths. Also after reading some of the other reviews, I want to say this to the owner.No offense, but you need to email Jessica yourself. Read more
One of the best places for hot dogs in Oklahoma, have loved it since I was a kid and still love it to this day. Great place for... some chili covered hot dogs. Read more
I made a DoorDash order weeks ago and my order was messed up when I asked for no onions and chili to have just cheese they put... everything on them. That is fine mistakes happen. But then I called today to just make sure there?s no onions on the coneysbecause I?m allergic. The employee then interrupts me several times and tells me that I ordered it wrong when I in fact haveordered before from here and ordered the exact same thing. I called politely. I didn?t deserve the attitude I got. Will notorder again. Read more
Great personalities and very warming when I ordered and also had a grateful small chat while waiting at the window for my order.... That usually doesn?t happen during the drive-thru! Read more
I've never experienced a Coney Islander that was this nasty. No management, bathrooms as well were totally filthy with buggers... all over the stall walls. Not one table was clean either. Read more
Love, love, love the food. My father, uncle and I each Live in different states without Coney-I-Lander. When any one of us are... visiting family in Oklahoma we always eat here at least once during the visit. Read more
Can't beat an original coney from Coney Islander, a must do Tulsa original! The best coney chili around! My once a month splurge... for lunch!! Always hot and fresh and made to order! As they say, "Haven't changed a bite since 1926!" Read more
Never been much for hotdogs but took my newly immigrated from Thailand family there and had one of the kindest patient with us... greating anywhere You may not understand if you haven't been in this situation, but at every turn I want my new family to loveAmerica and the graciousness of that team on my visit was so amazing... Can't say thank you enough Read more