Reviews for Mitchell's Fish Market in Brookfield, WI
Got takeout with a quick and courteous hostess. Ordered it from the bar, food took only 10 min to prepare. It was delicious!!... So much more flavor than I was expecting for a simple fish and chips lunch special. They use a lot of aromatic herbs for thefish and fries. Staff were all super nice and made good conversation too. I'll definitely be back here many more times in thefuture. Read more
Me and my husband we both had a satisfactory experience. I tried Oysters for the first time. The staff is friendly. We were done... really late but still the lady who was assigned our table asked us if we wanted desert. Nice place. Good quality food. Read more
Good good nice ambiance I didn't get a picture of my dinner in I had the salmon ?? just the turtle cheesecake,everything was... great. Read more
If you like fish and seafood you simply can't go wrong with Mitchell's Fish Market. We had grilled halibut with veggies and... smashed red potatoes and it was excellent. The bar is also well stocked, with both a quality wine list and premium cocktails.Highly recommended. - On a follow up visit we had their shiitake noodle bowl with salmon (superb, but only if you like spicyfood) and the fish and chips, and it was again excellent. We're yet to have a bad or average dish here, and our server wasdelightful. Read more
This was my first visit and I was extremely satisfied. The reviews were good and helpful and also very accurate. I started with... the Lobster Bisque and it was creamy and had good flavor. No actual Lobster meat in it though. I dipped the fresh sourdoughbread into it and really liked it. For the entree, I had the Mitchell’s Market Trio that includes grilled shrimp,crab cake andgrilled salmon. Crab cake was the star it was very good. Asparagus and red potato mash were also tasty. Overall nothing tocomplain about since the staff was attentive and always around with a great attitude. I’ll certainly be back. Read more
I have been in this place twice, one for lunch and one for dinner. For lunch, I ordered the Tuna Bowl, and it was delicious,... very fresh and balanced. For dinner, we order the Tuna poke as appetizers for share, again, very fresh and balanced, reallygood (if you like raw fish). As main course we tried the crab stuffed salmon (very good) and the ginger crusted salmon (good,but could be tasteful). Read more
Make reservations. For some reason I was expecting a bigger variety. There were a few choices besides the fish. Zack was an... amazing waiter!!! The scallops were a tad over done but the dish was tasty. Read more
We ate here for Thanksgiving and it was all very good. Charla was an excellent waitress and the food was very good. My... girlfriend had the turkey meal and I had Pecan crusted Trout. Along with the Sharks Finn cake and a piece of Pumpkin pie. Willbe back for Christmas and then my birthday. Read more