• Open:
    06:00 AM - 10:00 PM (CDT)
  • Cuisine

    AmericanNorth American

  • Features

    Takeout , Delivery , Non-Contact Takeout

  • Dietary


Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Google Reviews

K Lambrecht

SANDRA - I called trying to replace a certain type of gift card. I told Sandra on the phone that I was looking for a white Casey's gift card. At first she told me that they had it, so I said "great you have the white one?" Then she told me no. I was confused so I asked her again, then she stated it was store policy that she couldn't tell me on the phone. I explained to her that I did not live nearby and that if she could get me to anyone else or her manager. I was pleading a little bit with her. She then said to me "go ahead and cry" I then asked her to give me to the manager and she said Nope and hung up. I then drove to the store to talk to the manager. I spoke to the manager and to Sandra. When Sandra was asked by the manager if she had said "Go ahead and cry" Sandra said yup so matter of fact. I then told Sandra she can't talk to me like that on the phone, and then she said she thought I was a scammer. I said I asked you to give me to someone else and you told me to cry and Sandra gave me several backhanded apologies. Saying stuff like "I'm so sorry but you were acting hysterical", "you kind of acted like a scammer" Every time I tried to talk, Sandra spoke over me. She would say "Yeah you were doing this that's why I said that" I'm in disbelief. No one apologized to me. The manager barely acknowledged it. Sandra started talking about me in front the the manager when I was trying to explain to her that I was upset by her words. I'm disgusted by this Casey's. Do better.

Kayla Wyma

Night shift people are very rude. Went to order 4 pizzas asked for the order to be read back to make sure that the everything was correct. I got told that they didn't have time for this. I asked for a manager and they don't have one on night shift. They didn't have time again to go over the order so ended up canceling. I understand it gets busy I have worked at a Casey's but I always made sure my customers were cared for and got what they needed. I NEVER EVER told a customer I was to busy. It only takes a couple seconds to read it back.

Sarah Rauch

Amazing customer service! That?s just the tip of the iceberg! There food is outstanding! No matter if you grab from the Warner or cooler case everything is tasty! Ordering for pickup, you can never go wrong. I drive out of my way to take my business here!

Dena Bear

O stars. When they have pepperoni pizza at lunch, the darn card reader doesn't work. Never have can Pepsi stocked and a person only has so many minutes for break. I will stop going there altogether. Waste of time and energy. Casey's in general is a no go for me anymore. Very much lost their customers service. and this customer

Tammie Jensen

If I could give zero stars, I would. Sick of always waiting twice as long as estimated wait time(go in the time it says to, then it's not even started). Not even a lot of tickets, just staff that doesn't care. We keep going because kids request it obviously, but it's getting a bit ridiculous. 6 months later- Still continue to have issues. Cheese stick recipe change is great, but pizza undercooked tonight. How do you mess up how long a pizza goes through the oven?! I just wish they would find some staff that cares. Even stood at the register waiting for a few minutes while 2 cashiers just sat and talked(yes, they saw me). Also had the same issue of going in 10 minutes after anticipated time and it hasn't even gone in the oven.

Joseph Garrison

I've stopped at this gas station a few times on a long drive. I've never had bad pizza/burgers, the gas pumps always seemed to work ok, and the people working there seemed like they didn't hate their jobs. I'd give this a solid 3. Nothing memorable, that's a good and bad thing. Solid choice for a quick snack and some gas.

Tako Games

Have had numerous issues with the food in the warmer, for the past couple of months things were ending up highly underdone. Ive had to throw the cheese potato bites in the oven every time i bought an order. I got food poisoning off a sausage egg and cheese biscuit sandwich. Recently things have been getting better cooked but now things arent getting labeled. I absolutely dont like Canadian bacon. There was only 2 slices of pizza in the warmer. Both looked old but i was hungry so I took one. They werent labeled so i thought it was cheese and ended up being canadian bacon. I do enjoy Casey's food but too many issues anymore.

Trevor Lamb

Best taco pizza of all the Casey's I've eaten at. Came fresh out of the oven right on time with plenty of the salsa bean sauce. Generous amount of chips. Extremely friendly and helpful staff that have been welcoming ever since I moved to this town.

More Google Reviews

Looking for somewhere to eat? Here at Casey's General Store we have a wide selection of american food to choose from and we're located right in Brooklyn. Find out about our tasteful food, like our chicken. Be sure to check us out to find out more about our feature meals. Feel free to call us at (641) 522-3188!

Sauced Pizza And Pub - italian (10.8 mi)
A & M Cafe - american (14.22 mi)
The Periodic Table at Hotel Grinnell - american (14.31 mi)
Ice House Drive-In - american (14.32 mi)
Pagliai's Grinnell - italian (14.41 mi)

Towns near Brooklyn
Grinnell, IA (15 mi), Toledo, IA (20 mi)

Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Mexican, Asian or Italian in Brooklyn. Dietary need? Let us show you all the vegetarian, vegan or gluten free options. Search Sirved for things like burgers 🍔, steak , pizza 🍕, soup 🥣 and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
lunch menu for casey's, menu for casey's, casey's in brooklyn menu, casey's menu photos, casey's in brooklyn reviews, 108 1st st