Reviews for Portland Pie Company in Brunswick, ME
I'm not from New York or Italy or Chicago, so I'm by no means an "expert" on pizza. However, receiving two different pies that... were both raw was quite hard to miss. Not even undercooked. Raw. Like soft dough that was sticking to my hand. Oh and let's notforget the hummus appetizer that we ordered in the name of health. I felt real healthy when I got the bread and veggie sticksyet no actual hummus. That's right. A hummus appetizer with no hummus. That's just insane. Kind of like my bodies reaction thenext morning. Insane. Read more
I noticed the jem of a spot right off Main Street and Brunswick. I was greeted by staff with the small town warmth and instantly... felt as if I was a regular. The staff was phenomenal! My server was Gabby and I am so glad she was. She provided some of thebest service I have received in a while. She was sweet, attentive, and patient. I ordered the baked potato fries in the Arcadiaturkey Apple sandwich. Not sure what magic they put in their fries but they are scrumptious. Crispy, plentiful, and flavoredwell while topped with melted cheeses bacon and scallions served with the side of sour cream. The sandwich has convinced me thatI'll forever put apples on my turkey. The combination of roasted turkey breast, Brie, fresh greens, and Granny Smith Apples wastruly inspired. If you get a chance to visit this spot don't hesitate for a second you will not be disappointed! 10 out of 10 Read more
Waited for over an hour for a 3 pizza order. After multiple "I'm sorry for the delay" and "it will be another 5-10 min" I... cancelled the order. The manager came and instead of offer an apology he went directly to the register and hand me a giftcertificate maybe to buy my silence? I think he needs better training to handle a situation like this. Not a good experience Read more
I've found Portland Pie to be inconsistent in the past. But on the night we were there (a Monday night, one of the few places in... town open on Mondays and packed), the pizza was on point. My son and I each got different pies, I got the Korean steak special,and he got the Monaghan steak bomb. Both were excellent. We ate at the bar and bar service was terrific, with an attentivebartender and a great selection of micro brews. There's a lot of competition for the pizza dollar in my area, and it appears PPhas stepped up their game. I won't forget that next time I'm hankering for a pie. Read more
Friendly atmosphere. Sit in the bar or the dining room which was a little quieter. We had the Moosehead pizza, thin crust, which... was crispy and delicious. A great mix of veggies, pepperoni and sausage, and cheese. Service was friendly and the pizza came outquickly. We had a nice evening and a good meal. Highly recommended Read more
First time going here and I thought overall it was good. The pizza I got was good, wasn't super great and that could have just... been the type I got. Service was great. Didn't take to long to get everything but we also got their late evening when not muchpeople were around. Got a specialty pizza Moosehead with beer dough and a kids cheese pizza. My kids seemed to like it and ateher kids pizza. It's small around 7 inches. I would go again and just try another type of pizza. Read more
This was not our first choice but there was a 45-minute wait at the other restaurant. Got seated quickly as there is quite a... bit of seating. Upbeat atmosphere and our waitress, Kendra, was knowledgeable and cheerful. We ordered the Caprese Sliders andtwo slices of pizza. The sliders were amazing! The balance of ingredients was spot-on. This is an excellent appetizer. Fordinner we split two slices, the Great Diamond and the Nor'Easter. Both were good in their own right. We both preferred the boldflavors of the Nor'Easter. Great atmosphere, perfect service, delicious food. Glad the other place had a wait longer than wewanted to wait. Hooray! Read more
Absolutely a waste of money! Ordered pizza at 3:45, they said 47 mins making it ready at 4:32. I arrive at 4:28, right off I... should have been suspect when I saw the pizza's sitting on an unheated shelf like you would buy at Walmart. After the frontcounter, with an uninterested face and no greeting, asked "what do you need?" I gave the name for the order, as soo as shehanded me the boxes I could already tell they were lukewarm at best. When I got home I found what you see in the pictures, thecenter was a greasy mess and the outer edges of the slice pulled apart from it. With a spatula I managed to get two while slicesto the plate. At this point I had to toss them in the microwave since they were less than room temperature. I managed to eat onewhole slice and the crust from the other hoping for some redeeming feature to justify the nearly $70 price tag. But none werefound, the center was gummy and chewy and the flavors mediocer. U fortunately the other pizza was just as bad, the dough heldtogether a little better but only because it had the consistency of leather. At any rate we threw the rest out and went toMcDonald's. Somebody please bring Pizza Hut back to the Brunswick/Bath area, twice the pizza at half the price. Read more