Reviews for Conestoga Style Pizza in Bryn Mawr, PA
We like this place a bunch. Good pizza and good service.
Pizza never disappoints! Consistently good!
Not sure what is going on with Conestoga style pizza but wasn't very satisfied with my order. The pizza stromboli had no taste... and pizza fell in that same category. I pray that they can right the ship. Read more
I ordered from them a million times and everything was great. I am a heavy tipper and the guy that delivers is a very nice... man. But then just today, 6/25/2022, I ordered two Pizza's. One plain cheese and one with onions, peppers and jalapenos. Theone with extra toppings came with a ridiculous amount of cheese. I called them to ask for a new one or to just return the onethey sent and get a refund. The person answering the phone was extremely polite. He then said, hang on one minute. I waitedfor a few minutes and then a person came on and said "IF YOU WANTED LIGHT CHEESE, THEN YOU SHOULD SAY LIGHT CHEESE". I couldn'tbelieve I was getting yelled at. I had been ordering from them for a long time. Basically, weekly. This my first complaintand the person was completely hostile. At first, I tried to say that it wasn't light cheese, or regular cheese but he spokeover me. Yelling at me more. So finally, I had to yell back. I had no right to be treated in this manner. I won't beordering from them going forward. My advice to everyone out there, if conestoga style pizza, messes up your order. Justpretend you are on an episode of Seinfeld and ordering soup. Just don't say anything. The person running the show doesn'taccept comments. You eat what you get and you better like it. Read more
I ordered 2 BLT club sandwiches and received 2 of the most skimpy sandwiches I've ever seen. They didn't even use 3 pieces of... bread as a club sandwich is supposed to it was 2 pieces of bacon crumbled on 2 pieces of bread with very little else. I'm verydisappointed and will never order from here again. Thanks for literally nothing Read more
The cheese and sauce is DELICIOUS. Best tasting mozzarella and the crust was just slightly crisp. Perfectly cooked! My daughter... had a cheese burger and it was a thick pattie that tasted great! My 4 year old son ate 4 cheese slices, Wow! Excellent food,great in and out little shop. Don't miss it. Cheese steaks are popular too!! Enjoy!! Read more
Very good, very old school pizza shop cheese steak. You walk in and you know these guys have been making cheesesteaks together... for a long time. I am 99% sure it was a Conshohocken Bakery roll. I like my Conshohocken Bakery rolls. They melted the cheeseonto the role in the pizza oven, yummy. I love that. They season the meat nicely so it had a nice flavor. It was $8.50, you knowI didn't hate that. It was on the small side. Very good overall experience and the winner of my mini Bryn Mawr looking acrossConestoga Road at each other cheesesteak Showdown. Read more
Always excellent food. I've been going to this place for 45 years.