Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Buckhannon, WV
Best pizza I've had in awhile!!!
Ordered a well done, square cut BBQ chicken pizza no onions, 1st half add jalapeños 2nd half no bacon. I picked up my pizza... and drove back to my house just to see the pizza was made 1st half chicken, bacon and 2nd half jalapeño chicken. Completelybackwards of my online order and what the directions state on the slip glued on the outside of the box. So I do what a normalrespectable person does and drives back to the store and politely ask for it to me remade correctly. The worker looks at theglued slip then looks at the pizza and tells me It?s actually made correctly, but we?ll still remake it the way you want it.Obviously at this point I?m extremely embarrassed because it looks like I brought a pizza back for no reason and asked for it tobe remade. Im also holding up the line with one customer. I tell him no, if it?s made right Never mind I?m sorry. He explainedit?s fine we?ll remake it anyway. The worker reorders the pizza using my online order then says out loud don?t make the orderhow it?s says it?s supposed to be one half chicken, jalapeños, bacon and one half chicken bbq and no onions on all of it. Whichdoes nothing but embarrass me even more because he?s basically telling everyone I?m wrong. I walk out to my car and double checkthe slip and my online order just to find out I was right and the pizza was made wrong. Clearly at this point everyone in thestore is fired up because a customer just brought a pizza back stating it?s wrong but the worker told everyone it?s right. Ishow the female worker the slip and my online order and she explains I?m right and they just made it wrong, I really appreciatedher. Read more
The last time we ordered, we ordered a specialty "the works" pizza minus black olives with EXTRA CHEESE and it was perfect. I... was impressed with the fact that they actually put alot of cheese as I requested because some pizza places do not when u ask 4it. We also love the papadia but wish you could add extra ingredients like mushrooms to the philly steak. Read more
Ordered the Shaq-O-Roni, wasn't much pepperoni, no sauce and asked for well done and received burnt. Stopped eating Papa John's... about 20 year's ago because they changed their sauce but thought I would try it again, wish I wouldn't have now! It will beanother 20 year's before I try them again! Read more
Ordered a Shaq-o-Roni well done. There is a difference between well done and burnt, mine was burnt on the bottom, wanted light... sauce but I tasted very little sauce. Now for jalapeno bites, which I was looking forward to, there was absolutely NO creamcheese in them, just cut jalapenos wrapped in dough, these issues need attention!! Only reason I gave a 2 star rating was causedelivery was on time. Read more
Papa John's is a great franchise store. The pizza has been especially good lately. Always hot and always fresh. Give them a try
I buy 5 pizzas and get charged over $100..and on top of that when I order extra toppings for my pizza I pay for those extra... toppings but there NOT THERE!!! GET YOUR MEASUREMENTS CORRECT PAPA JOHN..I took the pizza back in and asked why am I paying forextra toppings but not getting them and this is what I was told" the more topping you order the less topping you get." But ISTILL HAVE TO PAY FOR THEM..this is bad business but it's okay papa John's Sam's pizza will definitely be taking my next order. Read more
Way over priced for an average pizza.