Reviews for Cookies & Cream in Buffalo, NY
Great place right near Shea's! Family friendly and very good sweets. Not cheap, but quality. Friendly staff gave the kids and... adults free flavor samples and made great suggestions off the menu. Very cute backyard feeling outdoor area with can jam,chalkboards, etc during summer months. Read more
The caramel cookie was the best and softest of them all and had a very nice rich buttery flavor.. really delicious. The brownie... with buttercream frosting is my favorite, even though I never eat sprinkles, I don't mind the sprinkles on these browniesbecause they're soft. One time they accidentally gave me the brownie with the chocolate sprinkles and I didn't like it at all,it left an awful aftertaste. Ive had cookies in the past from here, I've tried most of the flavors and although the taste of allof them was decent, i wasn't impressed because some of them were too hard and dry but it seems like they've improved this. It'sa really nice little shop, it's very clean, it smells amazing, the manager is super friendly and helpful. Lots of differentcookies, ice cream cakes, ice cream Etc and they have a nice little outdoor space in the back. Read more
Wow, so Guilford ice cream is pretty good. Can't say I've had it before. So solid on that. But the cookie. One of, if not,... the best cookies I've ever had. Peanut butter cookie with Reece's peanut butter cups mashed into it. Next July my birthdaycake is coming from this place. Recently ordered an ice cream cake for a birthday. Amazing, falls utterly short and describinghow good the cake was. Read more
Visited today for the first time. The shop is super cute and the staff was very friendly. We got the cookie sundaes and they... were amazing. They have tables to eat inside and a cute outdoor area to eat with lots of shady spots. Highly recommend. Read more
Awesome! Dog-friendly? they have pup cups, a fenced in area for sitting outside and a water bowl out for dogs. Super nice... inside. Smells amazing, like fresh baked cookies! Staff very friendly! Read more
I've walked past this place a hundred times and finally decided to stop in, if I'd have known how good it was I'd have stopped... sooner. When you walk in you gets hit with the smell of baking cookies. The prices are fair for the quality of the products theyoffer. I had a cookie sundae which was awesome! They have a nice variety of ice cream flavors to choose from. Read more
W O W. Even if you only walk in and smell the fresh baked cookies, it's worth going. The ice cream is so good. The homemade... waffle cones are tasty. Very cute place. Lots of room to sit outside in the back. Read more
this reminds me of every little bakery i visited in Amsterdam. walking by, the smell captures you from the street. inside,... employees are regularly turning cookies through their oven, and were very knowledgeable about the menu and answered all myquestions. i always wish I could finish the sundae I get, but I never can. Read more