Reviews for Dickey's Barbecue Pit in Buffalo, NY
Decent place at the start, but the last few orders have just been straight out disappointing. If you want undercooked meat,... missing items, and something completely different from what you ordered, this is the place. You?ll 10/10 times never receiveyour sides or sauces. Thinking about 3 meats? Enjoy two, because you?ll never get a full complete order from here. You wouldthink for the price of these dishes, quality and customer care would be top priority. I advise you to order elsewhere, becauseit?s always ?nothing we can do about it? and never ?enjoy your full order.?. Read more
First and last time order for me. Don?t make the same mistake I did, read the reviews before you choose to order from here. My... expectations for take out BBQ were not very high to begin with however this was an extreme disappointment. Portion sizes werelaughable for the price. Food lacked flavor. Honestly, the entire experience was just sad. Read more
Honestly I was really interested in the idea of this place but it really just let me down. First off, the pickup/carryout menu... states a lot of items that arent even present in the actual restaurant so I'm glad I decided to go in person because itcertainly would have been a fun little surprise to hear half my order was missing. The interior is great, and the aroma ispleasant but the food certainly leaves much to be desired. I ordered a chicken and brisket plate to which both of them werecold, small -portioned, really dry, and didn't have much flavoring. The only thing that provided any sort of flavor was thesweet bbq sauce I chose and getting an extra small cup costs $1 (which honestly tastes like Kraft BBQ sauce, I could go toDollar Tree and buy a whole bottle with that money). The mac and cheese was also okay... at least that and the potato casserolewas warm. I practically spent $45 ($17 each platter + drink/tip) for subpar food. A man came to check up on us on how we wereenjoying the food to which both my partner and I shyly smiled and said was fine. Overall, we ate it, but the price certainlywasn't worth what we were offered. I definitely wouldn't tell anyone I know to visit here for a good barbeque meal. Read more
Ordered the 3 meat meal with 2 sides and a baked potato with the works to split with a friend assuming we would have leftovers. ... Much to our surprise, while the ribs, brisket and jalapeno cheddar kielbasa were good, the portion size was very small. Thebaked potato did not seem to have all ingredients on it. That could be because when I ordered for a later pick-up time, theymost likely prepared it ahead and kept it in a warmer. I have no clue how they consider the sides to be "medium" in size. Barbecue beans and Baked Potato Casserole had no flavor at all. For the price, it was definitely not worth it. Will not orderfrom there again. Read more
It's really fast-food-quality BBQ. The only difference is; fast food is reasonably priced. Dickey's (at least this location) is... extremely over-priced. As of Fri Apr 15, 2022 the price of a tablespoon-sized pulled pork and brisket portion was $19 dollars.It included 2 sides ( I got mac & cheese, potato casserole, both were horribly commercial-tasting) and a drink served in asouvenir cup. I would rather pay $2-$3 dollars less for a standard cup. Seriously, what am I going to do with this big yellowcup? Read more
Dickies BBQ is a very decent place for a barbecue. I enjoyed everything we ordered. I suggest ordering online and picking up... your order, it's so much faster doing so. Ribs- (nice size bones) could've been better if they had more smoke to them. Pulledpork- a little dry, but taste really good with the bbq sauce provided Sausage- really good Coleslaw- really good (similar toKFC's) Potato salad- nice mustard flavor Read more
Everything we got was super fresh and full of flavor! Ribs are a must try along with their chicken. Dining room is open and busy... during lunch Read more
95% of the time, food is good and fresh. But I have found a fly in my side dish once. Customer service at the corporate level... did not help things. Read more