Reviews for Joe's New York Style Pizza in Buffalo, NY
Amazing food, great customer service. Owner seen my struggling taking out the food and ran to the door to open it. By far one of... the best pizzerias in Buffalo Read more
I?ve never had Joe?s before. I just so happened to be right down the street googling best pizza by the slice. I got one of each... the two times I?ve been there. Now I?m in love with the place. Getting hungry buddy thinking about it. Highly recommend. Read more
I'm the most patient person I know. And yet, a cold, dry pizza with waxy cheese, diced underripe tomatoes, and dried basil... flakes is what I got for over an hour's wait and $36.11. A Margherita pizza was what I'd ordered. First and last time. I'm nothappy. I had a guest in town and wanted to show them a good Buffalo pizza. This wasn't it. I can't even chew the crust, I may aswell have cut the box into little triangles and served that to my guest. :/ At that price point I expect better. Read more
We ordered a whole pie instead of slices because we wanted it to be fresh. It was.one of the best pizzas we have had in a very... long time. The crust was absolutely perfect. The garlic knots however were overcooked so that was a disappointment. Still, fivestars because the pizza was so good! Read more
The cust has a nice flavor, which is refreshing. The sauce is tangy and yummy, the toppings are fresh, plus they do not use... canned mushrooms. We got the Philly steak pizza. Read more
As a former New Yorker (born and raised) I was excited to try a NY Pizza from this location due to the good reviews. I got a... half pepperoni and half cheese pizza. The crust and dough were perfectly cooked but the pizza itself was lacking a lot offlavors. 3/5 rating because of the flavor. The pizza did look amazing. Read more
It's as good as it looks! I couldn't wait to take a bite (as you can see). Staff is friendly, dining area is kept clean, and the... service was swift and timely. Definitely worth the trip for NY style pizza! Read more
We had a group of 42 people. Most had 2 slices and a fountain drink (their special). We were in and out under 1 hour. Impressive... with that many people ordering and eating! Everything loved the New York Style Pizza!!! We all gave them a ?????????? We kepttheir information and we will be back!!! Great find!!! Read more