Reviews for Antioch Pizza Shop - Burlington, WI in Burlington, WI

Would love to give it a five star but it?s just not amazing pizza. The pizza special is a great deal, two slices of pizza and a... soda for about 6 bucks, so you?re definitely getting a full meal for 6 bucks which is hard to find nowadays. Downside is it?sjust not super great or memorable. Not bad by any means, just a good basic pizza, and for that reason alone I can?t give it 5stars. The staff was very nice. Read more

Picked up 5 different flavors of pizza. All excellent flavor and value. Very helpful and friendly staff also.

My first time trying Antioch Pizza Shop. Despite reading the reviews we opted to try it. Why I chose this place? It's nearby and... It's my sister's Birthday. Pizza is her favorite food and every year for her birthday all she asks for is a pizza and being at,The Bay at Burlington nursing home she doesn't get to have delicious food and we're from Racine so to bring her a pizza fromthere it would've been cold by the time we get here. 'Twas a good experience and we will be ordering from there again the nexttime Sister is craving pizza. I had no problems ordering and picking up my order, the young gal was very polite, well spoken andwell mannered on the phone AND while ringing up my order. Now on to the food, the double decker was quite large, bigger thanwhat I expected. It's what some places call a stuffed pizza, I didn't know that, I thought it was going to be like a virgincrust how the places in Racine call it. But it was BIG, delicious, cheesy and with enough sausage and sauce. My mouth issalivating talking about it even though I'm full ???? and it was well worth the money. But yeah, it was better than I expectedupon reading the reviews. Ohh and my fav fries are the crinkle cut and they had them and they were perfectly salted. Just let mesay, EVERYONE has their own preferences and their own expectations. I learned early on in my younger years after working for anauthentic Italian pizzeria and at my parent's Mexican restaurant that you have to accept that everyone has their own tastepreferences and what 5 other people might love there's 1 person who will hate your cooking and they have the right to, thatswhat makes us each individuals. So try things and places for yourself, dont just go by someone else's preferences and opinions.What they might dislike, you might love. Read more

I have been going to Antioch pizza for over 40 years. I love this place. But paddock lake and Burlington locations always mess... the order up somehow. Not life changing, but small details that they ask should be easy to follow thru on. Had a beef, I askedfor it to be dipped, came dry. Asked for ranch with the fried mushrooms, didn?t get any. Again, not life changing. But it?sbecome a regular thing in these locations. Alittle adult supervision might help. Just sayin. Read more

We stopped in for lunch here last week as it came recommend from some locals and we just moved to the area so we wanted to give... it a try. Not only was the girl who rang us up very rude. We asked what pizzas they had, she was very annoyed to have to tellus, she rambled off like 4 choices and my husband and I each picked one, 2 slices. As we were leaving we saw the sign for 2slices and a drink deal and asked her if it was a better deal to get the drink and she just goes "it's the same, did u want adrink" we just said no as she was already annoyed to have to help us in the first place which is a shame. Then we got home toeat and the slice of pepperoni I ordered must have been hours old and there was 1 piece of pepperoni on the whole slice.Wouldn't have been bad pizza if I ordered a cheese slice but unfortunately the overall lousy experience I wouldn't return orsuggest to anyone to try which is a bummer because I was excited and hopeful to love it since we are in that area often. (Eventho the pizza isn't bad the lack of customer service and lack of toppings was a turn off) Read more

I really wish there was a way to reply to the store's response, take note that they attack everybody that leaves a negative... review. No need to lie to somebody who used to run restaurants and went to culinary school. They are clearly using pre-madeingredients yes they may chop some vegetables but that is it. I did not say we did not get the ingredients we ordered as I ambeing scolded for, I am merely saying they overcharged for what they offer Let's see how far this escalates and this post getstaken down... $30.00 for a frozen pre-made, thin crust pizza!? Seriously?!? This place uses pre-made crusts that they just slaptoppings on and overcharge. We ordered their so-called supreme/ deluxe pizza which consisted of nothing but sausage, onions andmushrooms. Crust was flavorless and sauce was nothing but tomato sauce out of a can with no seasoning. If I wanted a frozenpizza I go to the store or order from a fast food chain. We will never be back. How can they justify this cost? Just tosprinkle a few toppings on top of a pre-made frozen food item!? We dined in on 4/7/22, they close at 8:00 but yet they shutdown the soda fountain at 6:30 for cleaning, so if you bought a beverage you're out of luck. Read more

I've been eating at the original Antioch pizza shop since I was a kid. Was happy when new locations started opening closer to... home. This burlington location has not lived up to our expectations. I ordered 2 orders of bacon cheese fries today afterdeciding to try them one more time. I ordered my fries "crispy" and both orders were soggy and gross. The original fries tastedrubbery. I would highly recommend going to the paddock lake location and skipping this one. Read more

Ordered pizza and side of onion rings. Went back in to complain after seeing the $4.55 onion ring order and this was the... replacement (first bag had even less!). They were good but HARDLY worth the price? Pizza was good but this was ridiculous. Read more