Reviews for Pizza Pie in Butler, PA
The establishment doesn't look very impressive and needs some major overhauling but I'm not here to eat the building. The pizza... is very good, from the dough to the sauce. We have never been disappointed. Read more
Pretty good pie, sauce could be better. More like something that would be on a good pasta not a great pie. But I have had some... of the best in the country. IE. Lou Malanoto's Chicago, Gio's east,... Read more
I called on Monday and ordered pizza to be delivered the next day at 11:15 for our lunch at BIHS. When it didn't show up after... waiting about 10 minutes, I called. I was told "it's sitting here. It will be there in 10 minutes." That's great! We will enjoyeating our lunch in the few minutes we have left. The pizza was very good, but I won't order from there again. Read more
Thought I'd pass along my experience with Pizza Pie today - 10-17-21. Having recently moved into the Meridian area I figured... I'd try them out and searched the web for "Pizza Pie on Evans City Road" in order to peruse their menu. When I located it (ohby the way I've since found three) the price seemed a tad high but thought I'd give it a go anyway. It should be noted that thepage I'd retrieved noted the correct phone number and address. When I picked up my order I was given a price significantlyhigher than the one that was advertised, which I, of course, questioned. Unfortunately at that point I was accosted for usingthe wrong website . . . who new. It was infuriating to be verbally insulted and rudely treated for what was obviously unbeknownto me. Not so much as a dollar was offered as a recompense as a result of their misnomer. Ironically I was told by thecashier that three other customers that day mentioned the exact same scenario and a fellow in line behind me made a very similarcomment. Sadly, they've lost my business. Read more
Get takeout for lunch during the week sometimes - great pizza, amazing hoagies ( I get the Italian typically), fresh ingredient... salads (the steak is real!), and their homemade Italian dressing is so good. Love to support local businesses that provideconsistent & good quality food. Read more
Pizza Pie has become our Friday night dinner place for quite some time now. The pie is awesome, but what I really fell in love... with is the dinners! Stuffed shells is my regular, and they are amazing. The dinners come with several breadsticks & a salad-but not just any boring salad- this sucker is LOADED with all kinds of goodies. If you are someone like me that eats the saladfirst, only eat half! You'll never see the rest of your meal because you'll be entirely too full after the whole thing! Read more
Hands-down best pizza in Butler. Very consistent quality, always on time, great pricing, and the BEST TASTE!!! I would have to... say I am probably the number one pizza fan and would eat for dinner seven nights a week if my wife would let me and this placeis the best. I moved out here from Pittsburgh so I was pretty spoiled down there but as a miracle I found Pizza Pie route 68.They don?t even deliver to us so we have to drive to pick it up and it?s still our go to spot every week and I stronglyrecommend you do the same. Thanks guys keep up the great food! Cheers! Read more
Excellent food great delivery people and you get your food when they say if not earlier and hot