Reviews for Third Eye Pies in Butler, PA
I'm so happy to see a pizza place in Butler that's different and unexpected. I've tried several and I think the pierogie pie was... the best. The crust is thin and crispy and I love it but it might not be for everyone. We get it door dashed so I can't speak tothe service, but I highly recommend stopping by. Read more
Taste is very fresh and high quality. Fun options. Environment and staff are friendly. Price is right. Will definitely visit... again. Read more
The staff is very nice and the pizzas are pretty good. I wish they offered a different crust though. I am not a fan of the thin... crispy crust. If they would offer a crust like Blaze pizza has in Cranberry Township I would give this place a 5 out of 5 stars. Read more
Visited from out of town and this placed looked very enticing from the pictures on their website. Great concepts, love the... naming conventions. When we got there, it wasn't as impressive. For having three kinds of gluten free crust, there were a lotof pizza styles/toppings that could not be made fully gluten free, which was disappointing (breaded chicken, gravy had gluten,Alfredo had gluten, majority of dessert pizzas had gluten - all of which can easily be made gluten-free - no gluten-freepre-made desserts to choose from). The pizzas themselves were just alright. Flavor and looks-wise. They looked better on thewebsite, as the creation execution seemed rushed and underwhelming. The manager had a very uninvolved attitude, while theemployee making most of the pizzas seemed nice enough, but inexperienced. Despite asking the manager for help, help only camewhen the third employee came out of the back room (she was extremely helpful and personable - kind of made up for the othertwo). Overall, we had planned to go there a second time on our trip to try more options, but after the first visit, we decidedto forego the second trip because it just wasn't as good as we were expecting. Blaze Pizza has a similar pizza-making concept(subway-style create your own), but the execution is better and service seems more welcoming. On the positive side, we loved howthe interior was decorated and the pricing was good. It would have been a better experience had they put as much care into theproduct as they did the look of the store and marketing. Read more
I knew what this restaurant was like going into it as my family member has eaten there multiple times. I enjoyed that you could... build your pie or pick a prebuilt option. There were many options for vegetarian, vegan, and gluten free diets. There was alsothe option to not use tomato sauce, which was helpful for a family member. I thought the design and layout out of the restaurantwas cute and unique. I thoroughly enjoy my pizza. Read more
This was our first time here and we really enjoyed the pizzas! Next time we're bringing the whole family so we can try a dessert... pizza too! I had a chicken parmesan pizza and the husband had something with peppers on it and he was really pleased that it hadsome real spice to it! It was just over $30 for two pizzas and two drinks. So, not ridiculously high but not cheap either lol.The options were really unique and fun though and craft items like this often are a bit more. We thought it was worth the price.Decor was cute, the theme of the restaurant was fun! We only had one little problem and that was the sun. Unfortunately the suncomes directly in the front windows and makes it almost uncomfortably bright to eat in store. I'm not going to take a star offbecause who can control the sun? ???? But...some shades or solar film would go a long way toward making dining in morecomfortable. They seem to do a good pick up/take out business and I really hope the people of Butler can support this placebecause it's a fun, tasty option when we're looking for somewhere to eat. I'd like to see it stay around for a while. Read more
Was very excited about the concept of this pizza place, the design and aesthetic are very appealing. Expected to find something... like Sublime playing inside considering all the hippie/psychedelic style decor, instead nothing but country ballads. The onlinemenu doesn't make clear the size of the pies that are available, glad I went in to order otherwise I would've been verydisappointed in the size of the "half pie." Setup inside looks more like an ice cream shop or a subway. Ordered the Nashvillehot pie and the Mac and Cheese pie. The bacon on the Mac pie may have been kept above safe food storage temps (bacon on themakeline was piled far higher than the refrigerated walls of the container keeping it room temp for too long) and was clearlyrancid upon eating, rendering the rest of the pie inedible. The menu also doesn't make clear that the "crust" is a thin crackerstyle. Disappointed, will not return. Great concept idea, terrible execution. Read more
Very good pizza. Thin crust. Bottled non-alcoholic drinks.