Reviews for Indian Creek Steakhouse in Caldwell, ID

Well, people kept saying it's good. Tried it for the third time with a different group. Still nothing to rave about. My rare... steak came out more medium. And my gf's medium rare came out done, like no pink. Fries were greasy as bacon strips. If I'mpaying $50 for steaks. Maybe making them right? Not my go-to steakhouse. Read more

This place is great for a family dinner! Came in on a Monday night with my family. They were short handed but still made us feel... like the main customer. Staff were very attentive and we were able to be seated right away. Wine list is short but diverse.Cocktail menu looks wild - we didn't try it but there were some interesting items to say the least. Steaks and burger werefantastic. Loaded baked potatoes were wonderful as well. Chocolate cake was excellent. Atmosphere was comfortable and laid back.Will definitely return!! Read more

So I'd never been before and since my boss was buying a coworker suggested we go. First - The place is HUGE! Multiple seating... and bar areas including an upstairs where we sat. The building is old and the updates have kept much of that character whichwas nice to see. It was a Friday about 6pm and I was worried the wait would be long, but we were seated right away and ourserver was prompt and helpful. I had the Dude (a steak) with fried potatoes and some beans or something in a cup. The steakwas cooked perfectly although the cup of stuff wasn't my thing and the potatoes were as expected. Everything was good - but - Icouldn't believe the prices. This is easily the most expensive steak house I've been to and honestly I don't feel the qualityand quantity matched up. The meal I got was 25.99 (basically the cheapest thing on the menu) and I had water to drink and with1 appetizer that was.... less than appetizing, our bill was over 85 with no alcohol. I've spent less on far better before so Icouldn't imagine spending the 50-80 or more on some of the other items there if the quality matches what I had. The atmosphereis cool, but I'll save my steak money for Texas Roadhouse. Read more

Only giving two stars because when I first got there it took them forever to check me out when I ordered to go! The hostess had... an attitude. The food is exactly what the girl on the phone said bar food. The French dip and the dipping sauce extremely salty.The fries needed to be cooked longer. Read more

I love the atmosphere here. That's the first thing that caught my eye. Food was very good. I had the finger steaks, a friend had... the pork nachos, and another friend ordered the pork chop. All tasted excellent. Adriana was an excellent waitress! Thank uAdriana! Would recommend for a good meal and fun western charm! Read more

For many years, we drove past this place or talked about it with other people, only to finally make reservations for the entire... family before we looked at Christmas lights in the plaza. It was a special night for our family. Our annual Christmas lightswalk, with pictures and hot cocoa. Everyone told us how good Indian Creek Steakhouse was. Well, tonight must not have been thenight to go! We were very disappointed. The table was not ready when we got there. Honestly, I get that, but when yourrestaurant personnel act as if we are inconveniencing you because you have to rearrange an area for people to eat (they had aprivate party cancel at the last minute, and they had to move tables), that is a problem. Then we got seated, and during thedrink order, we were rushed by the server to tell her what we want, only to wait for about 20 min for the drinks to show up.When she brought the drinks up for the two different tables without a tray, as she attempted to place my drink on the table, allfour drinks tilted and she ended up spilling my husband’s drink on my clothing, and onto an adjacent chair which had my purse,a child’s coat and my daughter’s iPod. After that fiasco, it took another 20 minutes to get the food order in andapproximately 45 min to an hour later to receive entrees. We were told about the big party on the other side of the restaurant,the busy game room and packed band areas, and how they had to move things around where we were sitting to accommodate us. Again.it felt like we created an inconvenience for them, as she said it was good we were able to fit you in. It’s not like wedidn’t have a reservation…they only knew about us coming to the restaurant for about two weeks now. We were told that theyhave four kitchens. Apparently one the them doesn’t know how to cook shrimp since my expensive plate had raw shrimp cominglingwith my somewhat cooked steak. I have pictures of the seasoned cold, gray shrimp. It didn’t help that the rest of my meal wasco Read more

Love the restaurant’s atmosphere and music. Seems like a great place for a date night ?? Menu is pricey to go with the kiddos,... we went during happy hour (2pm-6pm) so not to bad, $5 nachos, $8 burgers, which were great ???????? we also ordered the 1/2rackof beef ribs there were nice and juicy. Read more

This is a hidden gem in the middle of a road trip. Their food is nothing short of amazing, kobe beef was cooked great. Drinks... were very tasty. This place is absolutely huge. Don't let any of the photos foul you. I walked around with a waitress and shelet me take photos of each room. It is huge! Ask about the high end drinks, you won't be disappointed. Each of of my photos isfrom a completely different room. Read more