Reviews for Wally's Pizza in Caldwell, OH
I've been eating here since I was a kid and they never fail to impress. Great pizza! Support local business
Still the best pizza ever! Used to live in Cambridge and whenever I come back I stop in for a few slices. It never disappoints!
At first glance the pizza doesn't look impressive but I have to say it's most certainly delicious. Their crust game is on point!... The staff was super accommodating and polite. Read more
Pizza is good. Square type DiCarlos 'knock off' pizza, but WAY TOO EXPENSIVE! Competitors charge $1 a slice, Wally's charges... $1.65 in St. Clairsville Ohio and a whopping $1.90 a slice in Caldwell. Wow crazy. 4x4 paper thin crust. Just not worth the$$. I know it's expensive to open a nice pizza shop, which the St.C location is, but if you lower your price a little you willsee you will sell twice as much. Good pizza, just too expensive. And I'm sorry, the cheese blend is supposed to be Provoloneand Mozzarella.. good quality cheese does not turn yellowish when cold. Read more
Really good food, large portions for the price. Dry rub wings, subs, calzones, buffalo ranch pizza, and more...
Meat lovers pizza was the best I've had.
I went in today for the first time and the staff was so friendly and helpful. I needed to feed my coworkers and I had no idea... what to get. I was exhausted and I wasn?t able to think straight. Brad and the two girls working the front were so great. I gothalf size party pizza and a bunch of the greatest wings I?ve ever had! Thank you Wally?s!! Read more
Best pizza in the country, owners are awesome people.