Reviews for Nicolletti's Pizza in California, MD
Unpretentious local pizza/sub/salad joint with above average food. Excellent crust on pizzas. Portions are quite reasonable for... the price paid. Many ingredients are made in house, not sourced from restaurant supply companies. Does take-out and delivery aswell as sit down service. Has two separate small banquet rooms. Orders placed at counter and then delivered to table. Staffgenerally friendly - it may take a little time to get attention. A few booths needed bussing on our most recent visit. Overall,a superior option to the plethora of chain restaurants in the area - it has become a go to place for when we're in this part ofSt. Mary's County. Read more
We ordered the thick crust chicken parmesan pizza and it was delicious! It is definitely the best in this area. We also ordered... pizza rolls and bacon cheese fries. The pizza rolls were also good. The fries were lacking on the portion size and cheese. Itwas a bit pricey for what we ordered but it was still worth it. Read more
Amazing pizza with the best staff ever! Our large group desperately needed food last night and didn't arrive until a half hour... before closing. The staff was so kind and accommodating. Never made us feel unwelcomed, even when the kids in our group were ahandful. I hope management sees this and gives props to the crew that worked last night! Read more
Probably the best pizza around, but the last three times I've ordered and then come to pick up, my order has been lost. Getting... really sick of coming in expecting almost done pizzas then having to wait 45 minutes as they start from scratch. Once is anaccident but this is a trend I'm not enjoying. Read more
Best pizza in town, nice service, and conformable seating.
Best pizza in the county. Hilarious dinner tonight, though. I asked for a 12 slice pie as that (usually) results in the... perfect slice size. What I got instead was this abomination 10 slice. C'mon guys, you bake the best pie, let's stay on targetwith the pizza cutter. LOL Read more
Pizza is good taste fresh pepperoni is great pineapple taste fresher than most places. Would like some more garlic flavor and... maybe leave in the oven 2 more minutes I like a lil more crisp. Not a bad pizza. Read more
Very good pizza, lots of meat on the meat lovers (so greasy! But good!) Excellent gluten free crust, but only in small size. ... The web site lets you order gluten free in med & large, I got a call a few minutes after I ordered, letting me know. Hepleasantly helped me adjust the order, and had the payment adjusted already when I got there. We got carryout, but when I atein, last time staff & ambiance were great. Read more