Reviews for Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza in Camillus, NY

We take out pizza and wings from here nearly every Sunday. The wings are perfect in cheeky monkey sauce and garlic parm. I... haven't tried much of the other sauces. The pizza is great. Not too much sauce and perfect crust every time. This time I didpepperoni with garlic on top and it was delicious. Read more

There's pizza, and then there's Toss & Fire. Yea, there are a lot of really good pizza places in syracuse. Pavoves...... Paladinos... Mario & Salvos, amongst many other really solid slices. T&F is in a different class of pizza. The freshestingredients I've tasted in a pie in a very long time. Cooked to order, and to perfection, in their operational wood fired oven.Literally nothing to complain about. We ordered a 3 Little Pigs and a Meatza, yes there is a difference, and both wereoutstanding. Paired that with a mix your own soft drink, and some fried mozzarella, which was also excellent, and we were sowell fed for like $42. Short money for a really excellent meal. Way more than we could eat on one sitting, literally took afull pizza home with us. Well worth the trip to Camillus. Read more

Got 'Bit of a Pickle' without bacon as I'm vegetarian. Definitely could've used more flavor that I'm sure the bacon provides,... but still good! Staff were very kind and attentive and my pizza came out quickly. Read more

Pizza is decent. Had the Four the love of cheese pizza. All i could taste was the burnt crust. Can only do small wood fired... pizza because they installed a small wood oven Read more

My meal was fantastic! I got the chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was so flavorful. I loved the garlic on it! one member of my... party didn?t like their pizza because they could only taste how burnt the pizza was. Personally I didn?t have that problem.Friendly Staff Read more

Food was fast and really good! The atmosphere was fantastic as well. The art style was very cool. The staff was friendly and the... experience was a solid 8/10. The food was probably a 8.5 to 9/10. My only gripes in my visit: This may have been a 1 off thinghowever it was worth mentioning the table I sat at was a little dirty, and the drinks were over priced quite a bit. However thatwas it really no other complaints! Read more

Really great pizza. All new flavors to tempt your taste buds. The salt potato pizza was awesome. The cheeky monkey sauce... terrific. Read more

Went there for the first time on Sunday. We've been wanting to try them for a while now. Have heard amazing things! But the... price has kept us at bay. We finally took the dive. Ordered online which was easy to use and navigate. I was a bit fan of theironline ordering. I ordered a 12" pickle pizza with roasted red peppers added and a 16" Philly pizza. Our total was in the high40s with a tip. We had timed the pizza for 1:15, I got text messages saying the order had been submitted. Everything was goingwell well no issues. Then 1:04 I got a text saying our order was ready. I completely understand it's hard to time orders, youcan't make it perfect but 11 minutes early isn't really acceptable. I timed it because I'd rather wait a couple minutes for ahot pizza then pick up one that's been sitting there. The store was clean and the staff was nice I would like to add. Nextcame the issues of the sizes of the pizza. Our 12" was barely over 10. And our 16" was also small. I've read through the reviewsand seems this is a common issue. I was happy to pay the price until I saw I lost a significant amount of bites due to how smallthe pizzas were. It's very clear to, I can't believe the pizza maker didn't remake them or offer a discount. We drove out ofour way to try them and was not impressed. I don't plan on going back. I didn't reach out to the store because we live 30minutes away and didn't want to go back out. Also the fact that the sizes are issues with multiple people make me think it couldbe an issue in the future as well. The pizza was delicious! I just wish we got all that we paid for. Read more