Reviews for Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub in Cape Coral, FL

We came to watch one of the FIFA world cup soccer games and the bar was super-crowded. We were blown away by the attentiveness... of the staff amidst the craziness and complimented our waitress in person. We asked her to send her boss over but were neverable to speak with the boss so we could make a compliment on our waitress' behalf. Big time applause to Overtime for thedelicious appetizers, (wings are the bomb!) and scrumptious pizza. All the staff we encountered worked in incredible unison andthey were super-diligent, attending to our drinks and cleaning the tables before we even asked. Food came very quickly for howcrowded it was! As a side note, when I used the restroom one of the toilets was not flushing properly and I was able to openthe back, lift the plunger, and flush it manually. The staff was already aware and working the problem however. By the time Ifinished in the restroom THREE staff members were there attempting a fix! Big time KUDOS to all staff for busting your humps atthe workplace, for your attentiveness, expedient bussing of tables, and for addressing issues and customer needs with seemingease. I highly recommend this establishment for excellent food and attentive service! There's a reason the crowds come flockingto Overtime as their venue of choice. Thanks so much for the great food and service. Read more

This place was many different things before OT. Finally something that stuck. The place is Fing huge so you’re never going to... wait on a table. Great local sports bar with awesome pizza. My favorite wings and nachos when I go to Florida. Pretty muchanything I’ve had was really good. Cool environment for sports and it’s family friendly. Read more

Wow what an amazing experience... We were lucky enough to bring in fresh caught fish right from the gulf and then the experience... here began... The owner welcomed us and made our experience the best. Service was on point too. The chef at overtime absolutelyout did himself. He took our fresh fish to a whole nother level... Absolutely perfect. One of our favorite places. Thank you somuch for a wonderful dinner and experience! Read more

We love eating at Overtime Pizza. Try to stop in to dine every other week for their pizza. I’d say it’s the best pizza... we’ve had in Cape Coral. Lots of TVs for sports enthusiasts. Servers seem very happy and are hustling working hard. Mgmt seemsto have their act together. Highly recommend. Their health inspections look solid as the quality and taste of their food. Irecommend highly. Read more

Had a wedding shower here today. Very awesome! Our server, Jacob I believe, was awesome. Stayed On top of drink orders, food... set up and ready to go on time, and went above and beyond to meet all our needs. The food was great too. Thank you for helpingto make this a great experience for us and the happy couple. Read more

Love the blue crab dip! The atmosphere is great and on game days there are TVS and projector. Parking can be tricky if it is a... big game day. Seating usually isn’t a huge wait time…most I have waited in 6yrs is 30mins. Read more

First time here and we were very pleased. Ask for Melissa because she is a fantastic server who hustles nonstop to make sure you... have everything you need. The homemade ranch dressing is yummy. My husband’s meat lovers Stromboli was loaded and a greatsize. Great choice of beers too! Read more

We've been getting cheese steaks and fries ever since you opened. Always fantastic!So we never ordered off the menu. Yesterday... we had a vegetarian pizza the crust was fantastic the flavor was great what a great surprise now we have two things that we willorder.Going to have to start trying new stuff off the menu more. You all work so hard and it shows! Thanks for being one of ourgo to places. Read more