Reviews for Rum Bay in Cape Haze, FL
We went here for our anniversary and had a blast. Melissa was our server and was perfect. We solicited drink suggestions and... they were perfect for us. I had a very good blackened mahi mahi sandwich and enjoyed it very much. Overall, we really enjoyedourselves! Read more
Great service from Dustin, food was excellent, broccoli cooked perfectly. Butter for the bread was awesome.
This place is a hidden gem! Take a short ferry ride out to the island, and after a very short walk, you?ll reach the... restaurant. We took our family there for a dinner and order lobster, shrimp, tuna steak. Everything was absolutely fantasticand our service added to the awesome experience. Beautiful views from part of the dinning rooms. This was a great place tovisit to have drinks, dinner, and great views. We can?t wait to go back. Read more
So fun!! Great seafood!! The lobster was decadent! Highly recommend the tacos and the bartender is attentive and makes a great... cocktail ???? Read more
Very disappointed with the food. It was terrible! Used the water taxi which cost $6.00 per person. Server has great, very... friendly and informative. We ordered Mahi tacos. The tortilla was cold, dry and hard. Two Snappers were not fresh and fried inold oil reused. Both were dark inside and not flaky. Baked potato was over cooked and dry. Terrible, terrible. Don't let thepictures fool you, it's all about the taste and freshness of your food. Manager removed two drinks, one snapper and taco mahimahi from the check. Read more
Vacation Dinner our last evening in FL (10/10/21) We took a 60 sec. car ferry across the water to get to the restaurant (NOTE!... We came in from the wrong direction, lol.) However, the restaurant was great! Food was outstanding and plentiful. Not used toshrimp that meaty, tender and flavorful. Our waitress was beyond exceptional (Lauren?). Anyway.... don't miss a chance for somegreat food & atmosphere in a great part of old Florida!! Read more
Great place to stop for a bite or just get a cold drink on a hot day. They don't have a lot of boat slips which is kinda... disappointing since you can only get there by boat or the ferry, but that's just life. The restaurant itself is nice and cleanand the wait staff is always friendly. We've been there several times but this time we only stopped into to get drinks at bar. Read more
We've now been here a few times and each time it has been a great experience for our family. We visited today for a late... lunch/early dinner taking our boys with us who had yet to make the trip over. The taxi boat ride is always fun, the Captainalways goes out of his way to accommodate and make sure the ride over is a good time. Our server tonight, Melissa, wasFantastic. We can be a lot at times and often a little louder than others but with respect. She was extremely flexible while weworked thru our ordering, drinks were out quickly, apps and food as well. The food here is always well prepared and we trulyenjoyed our service overall. We made sure to tip her very well for putting up with us...hahaha Anyhow, we love making thistrip out to Rum Bay, it has always been a great experience for us and plan on making many returns. thanks!! Read more