Reviews for Mario's Pizza And Italian Eatery in Cape May, NJ

Great pizza! Showed up right at 11:30 when they opened and it was NY style but slightly thinner and crispier. Very fresh ????

My companions were looking for good honest Italian food at a fair price and we found it at Mario?s! Pleasant, very relaxed... atmosphere ? clearly it?s a favorite of Cape May locals. The meatballs and spaghetti was excellent, as was the sausage andspaghetti. Excellent pizzas: fresh, flavorful, and obviously lovingly prepared. We?ll be back! Read more

OMG! Best pizza and Cape May and West Cape May! I?ve been there 3 times and it?s always gotten better. I can?t wait to do... Mario?s again! You guys do a great job. Thank you! Love the banana peppers with my pizza! Read more

Good food for a fair price and delivered to our rental.

After having so much seafood my family wanted a break from it and decided to stay with something nice and tasty. We hit the... jackpot with this place! We had a few slices to give it a try. and we were not disappointed. My family liked what we had beforethat we give them a second try and had a more hearty meal. So if you are ever in the Cape May area, stop by Mario?s and trytheir pizzas, you won't be disappointed, the food is great, the service is fast and the ambiance is great. Read more

Stopped in right before close and got two pepperoni slices. They were so delicious and just what we needed! My one bite review: ... 5 star google review, 7.4 Dave score. Read more

Mario?s Pizza is the freshest pizza joint in Cape May, I want to say you don?t have to pay for parking if your there for less... than 30 minutes which is totally dank! The pizza was so good we also had it for breakfast! The Neapolitan Margarita Pizza was A1and the Cheese Pizza sealed the deal! So if your ever in the Cape May area, stop my Mario?s for some banging fresh pizza! Read more

Never had a bad meal from Mario?s. The pizza is excellent and so are the cheese steaks. If you suffer from gluten intolerance... their GF pizza is the best around. If you find yourself in the Cape May area in need of a great slice Mario?s is the place.Never had an issue with service. The only negative thing I can say is the fries were soggy, but a few min in the air fryercrisped them up to golden perfection. Keep up the great work! Read more