Reviews for Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar in Cape May, NJ
This restaurant deserves 10 stars. The service and food is beyond good. The crab cakes were the best my wife ever tasted. My... grouper light, flaky and seasoned to perfection. We passed on dessert but my wife ordered a specialty drink from the menu. Itwas a mudslide with vodka and chocolate. Very tasty. Don’t worry about the calories. It was worth it. Read more
Went there on a Friday night at 7:00 p.m. with a party of six. The drinks were great. The food was all freshly made including... the pasta/ raviolis and the staff was very courteous. The hanger steak was awesome and perfectly cooked. We also have the angelhair carbonara which was really good and just the right amount. Overall, oyster Bay restaurant is an excellent place to eatwith a variety of great seafood and steaks. Will definitely keep coming back every year Read more
Ate here last night with the family, it was great! A Cape May staple. We went to the bar area after and they had a person... playing guitar and singing, so much fun! I loved the crab cakes. They’re not your typical heavy bread filling kind, superlight, almost like a tempura- different, but I really enjoyed them. Will be going back again as soon. Read more
Had a terrific dining experience with friends at Oyster Bay a few weeks ago! The food was fabulous and service was excellent... with an outstanding hostess who assured us she would tell our friends - who were having a drink at the bar - to join us at ourtable and she did. The interior is lovely too. My husband ordered the Frutti Di Mare which he said was delicious: theseafood was fresh and the scallops perfectly cooked with great flavor. I had the Veal San Marco which was scrumptious! I didnot finish it, had some wrapped to go, since I wanted dessert too (my indulgence and weakness). Our server whose name Ibelieve is Bobby suggested the bananas foster cheese cake and it did not disappoint, it was fantastic! Will be returning forsure the next time when visiting Cape May. Read more
Wonderful dinner last weekend! Service was great. Food was very tasty. Will definitely be back
Great spot for a great meal. Drinks and food were great. Only complaint is at the prices charged, the butter should be nice and... soft when it comes out with the bread. It's the details Read more
Very versatile happy. Waitress was experienced, food from apps to dinner was awesome. Can't wait to come back every... summer. Must have reservations or find a table at the bar. Read more
We had a much better experience than we did a few years ago. Bartender was on point tonight and food was delicious. Scallops... were sauteed perfectly and the sauce was devine. Oyster Rockefeller were average. Too much Bernaise sauce on top. But otherwisea good experience. Read more