Reviews for Peace Pie in Cape May, NJ
Stopped by Peace pie for dessert while in cape may and wow, so glad I did because it did not disappoint! Took me a while to... figure out which one I wanted MOST but ended up choosing the peanut butter blondie and YUMMMM! I loved it. My boyfriend got thecoconut cream and I may or may not have asked him for a bite and yup, even better (your bfs dessert always is). I woulddefinitely return, we came in the fall so no wait, everything was quick and easy. Staff was friendly. Come by and check it outfor yourself! Read more
Glad I got mine to go. These are so tasty if I had eaten mine at the shop, I would have gone back up multiple times for more. ... The great number of menu choices already have me wanting to go back. The sandwiches do not look like the pictures and they arevery, very frozen. Those are my two minor critiques, otherwise Peace Pie is one of my new Shore spots. Read more
So I had 1, and then proceeded to order another and then another. These chocolate shortbread cookies are crispy, buttery good!... Ice cream flavor and texture is smooth and on point. Personally, wish the "pie" part was fresh and not frozen, but obviouslythis wasn't a major deterrent because I kept stuffing my pie-hole with them at 1030PM. Coffee Toffee ????????? RaspberryChocolate Chip ???????????????????? Pumpkin Pie ???????????? Read more
Lots of flavors is the only nice thing I can say. 2 stars for a good concept and poor execution. She handing me a frozen solid... pre fabbed sandwich, it took about 15 minutes to enjoy a soft bite, nothing like the pictures, no chunks of toppings or mousseoverflowing, just thin layers of flavored cream. They don't even sell bottled water at least to go with their freezer hard icecream sandwiches. Save your money for scooped ice cream @ Ben & Jerry's, at least you can grab a drink there! Read more
So Many Flavors to choose from.. one is better than the next. I was eating these like tik take. Great stop for Ice Cream and... more. Definitely on your Cape May list. Read more
Very good! The selection alone is awe inspiring... and then once you finally pick one they are really good sandwiches too! Plus... they're open later so it's nice to be able to get dinner and then head over there for some ice cream if we don't get dessertwith our meal. Definitely a nice Cape May treat. Read more
Amazing every time! I'm always excited to come here. There are so many flavors to choose from and they are all delicious. The... one pictured below is called "Fall Harvest" and it has a cinnamon cookie with pumpkin ice cream and some kind of vanilla fillingwith rainbow sprinkles. It was very good! Read more
Greet ice cream stop. Fast to get food and well run. Menu can be tricky to find - here?s Oct 22s list.