Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Carle Place, NY

Sat down 15 minutes, no service. Watched 3 other tables directly surrounding us be served drinks & place orders - all were... seated after us. Couldn’t get anyone’s attention. We were the only brown ppl in the entire room. We left. At least 3 serverswere talking behind the bar. Not even water given. Read more

Don’t bother ordering from this location. They clearly either have a management issue or quality control. Ordered a pot of... meatballs and garlic knots. The knots as you can see we’re clearly inedible. Hard as a lump of coal. The meatballs were in awatered down marinara sauce. Never have we had such an issue. And of course they didn’t provide any bread w the order. Read more

Schedule a pickup. Followed instructions on text. Parked to the right of the door with my flasher on with a description of the... car. Waited 15 minutes. Never came. When in. Ask the person by order desk what was going on. She said she looked but did see me.All she had to do was turn her head to the left when going out the door. I was 20 feet from the front door. My food was wascold. Pizza wasn't good. Might have been better if it wasn't cold. Garlic wings were in some kind of milky cream. Buffalo Wingsand Ribs we good Read more

Gianna is the most friendly, patient, and best waitress! She makes sure you’re happy by ensuring your orders are just the way... you like them! We love Wings Tuesday because it’s buy one order of wings and get the second one free! Read more

Didnt know what to eat on thursday night, my wife and I stopped by anthony coals pizza and the garlic white sauce wings were so... good so good i come back for these wings again, i liked how these werent fried. Pizza was ok and knots were little doughy butgood flavor, and the server short girl was on point! Bubbly and always smiled and super fast with service! Pizza was ok though,not my style not better than my local pizza but service was excellent so i come back again! These wings better than anyrestaurants or buffalo wings near by though Read more

Our second visit in 10 days and were happy with the friendly service and had the pizza both times. Keep in mind every Wednesday... a large pizza is only $10, and if you download their app and enter your info you get a free pizza on your first visit! There'splenty of parking outside, and this intersection is the busiest in Nassau county. Unfortunately the menu did not include prices,a bit unusual, but the pizza is thin crust and tasty. There is a bar inside, a couple of large screen TVs, and low lighting. Iam looking forward to trying other dishes like the meatballs etc. All in all worth a visit, I found the pizza tastier and moresubstantial than Eddie's on Hillside Ave. Read more

Hands down the best wings ever! I know this is a pizza joint but I usually come here just for the wings. Got an order of 10... original wings tonight and a meatball & ricotta pizza. The wings were ready in under 5 mins. They are perfectly charred, falloff the bone, and great taste with the onions on top. The pizza was great too. Crispy thin crust With sweet tomato sauce, clumpsof ricotta, and tender meatballs. The wait staff were all very attentive and professional. Greeted at the door, satimmediately, and my waitress was there to take a drink order right away. Nothing like Anthony's coal fired. ???? Read more

I've tried other Anthony's which j thought was better. this location appears to have super thick bready crust. this pie was... requested with extra thin crust, and extra cheese. i could only imagine how think the crust would have been if I hadn'trequested "thin". the meatballs were a bit firm, unlike other locations i had tried where they're pretty soft and tender, notsure why. i would give other Anthony's locations I've tried (in NJ) over 4 stars, maybe even 5. but this locationdisappointed, more like 2.5 stars. at least the ingredients are still high quality even if they don't cook it well. Read more