Reviews for 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion in Carlisle, PA
Truly great experience! Not only was the food and selection of whiskey (obviously) and other beverages great, the waiter Rich... was phenomenal. We will be back and specifically requesting Rich. His personality, genuine approach and attentiveness actuallymade the trip. Thank you all and keep up the awesome food, drinks and service! Read more
A must go to restaurant! The food is delicious, and the beer is always cold! If you are a onion ring fan, Whiskey Rebellions are... a must try! Want a great server? Ask for Gena! She was fantastic and made sure our table was taken care of. Read more
Always a great dining experience. Just make sure to call ahead for reservations especially Friday and Saturday
Good food but VERY slow and inattentive service. After being sat we waited almost 15 minutes before we saw a server. We ordered... drinks and an appetizer. The drinks came quickly, but our appetizer took 45 minutes, and only came out after we asked. We thenhad to flag our waitress down to order additional drinks and entrees. She never refilled our waters, and we had to requestsilverware. Dinner took at least another 45 minutes to arrive. We won’t be returning, which is a shame because the food wasgood. But at $160 for two people we would expect more attentive service. Read more
This may be the best burger I’ve ever had. A lovely establishment, which sticks to its theme. It tells a brief part of history... - the Whiskey Rebellion - and has menu items appropriately named. The dishes looked delicious, and tasted even better. My wifehad the deviled eggs which were “devilishly” good. We expected 3 halves, not three whole eggs, so that was a great surprise.The Mifflin Bull Burger was fantastic, as previously mentioned, perhaps the best burger I’ve ever had. The onion rings weremassive and perfectly cooked. Think of the sound of crunching leaves or fresh snow, you could hear the crackle when biting intoit. The burger was perfectly moist and seasoned. The burger came with a house made ketchup on the side, but the burger didn’tneed it. The fries were crisp and seasoned with just the right amount of salt. For dessert, a gluten free cheesecake. As one mayexpect, a vast offering of Whiskeys. Convenient location, this place was incredible! Read more
Food was good, but we won't be dining here again. We went here as a date night and we're excited to try it out. The food was... great, portions were small but quality was great! The service was inattentive and though the server was nice, did not seemgenuine. We were there for an hour and our drinks were not refilled once even after checking on numerous tables around us.Overall it was just okay. Read more
We travel a lot and stopped in here on our way to Atlantic City. Got into town late, which we usually do and this place was... great. Had it all atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious food. Wonderful experience. Read more
Food was fantastic, onion rings were probably the best I've ever had. Shepard's pie was very good. Awesome bourbon selection,... although a little steep on some of the prices. Rarer bottles were priced decently fair. 9.5/10 overall. Read more