Reviews for Allegro Pizzeria in Carmel-By-The-Sea, CA

Wow This place is fantastic! We came here two nights in a row! First night we ordered two pizzas witch were delicious crispy,... hot and sauce was awesome! My sons ordered dessert as well, one ordered a small cannoli and the other a scoop of caramel gelatothey were in heaven! Second night we ordered pasta, fettuccini Alfredo with chicken and marina with sausage pasta and a kidsBolognese all three were fantastic, the Alfredo and sausage plates came with salads and garlic bread so delicious! my boys alsogot desert on night two. This time large cannoli and two scoops of caramel gelato. The service was fantastic our server Charliewas fantastic he was very attentive extremely polite and treated my boys like they were family. Good job guys i wish you all thevery best! Read more

I'm 95% positive that the owner is Italian. Or at least the cook is. However, the food was hit or miss. Loved their salads,... especially the Caprese salad. It had ample amounts of fresh basil leaves and mozzarella chunks. Balsamic was really great too.Then I asked for a calzone, which was not on the menu, and I'm grateful that the cook accommodated my request. It looked goodbut the dough, which I believe was a pizza dough rolled into a calzone, was not very good. I also tried their panini and it wasdry and unsavory. Also I think the grill leaves some quaint taste on the bread. Couldn't really pinpoint what it was. Read more

We had a wonderful dinner last night. The Ceasar Salad was excellent and our pizza was fantastic. We are definitely returning on... our next visit to Carmel Read more

Love the place. The pizza is very good and sometimes across the street is live music so you can enjoy your pizza.

A verry delicious place, a friendly staff. I spend two evenings for dinner. One time I got a pizza und the second one ... pasta. I feel like o eat in Italy. Minus one star, because the overcooked at the first time my pizza (I got a second one and got nothing to pay for it) and in the wintertime it's a little bit cold inside. Read more

Great pizza and good for kids. When we arrived hungry they had free table bread right away. Crayons and coloring for the kids... which is always a plus. My favorite Italian beers on tap. Pizza was delicious and served quickly. Toppings were fresh. When mydaughter mentioned she loved olives and the waitress happened to hear she brought over a complimentary bowl of olives forher....phenomenal service! So glad we found this place! Read more

Upon arriving in Carmel, we ordered a takeaway pizza from this restaurant and took it back to our hotel. When biting into my... second slice of pizza, I felt something rather hard. At first, I thought it was a piece of onion, which I then removed. Whenbiting down again, I felt something really hard between my teeth. Upon closer inspection, I discovered a 2-inch screw (nail)within the melted cheese - I was completely shocked & horrified, not to mention distressed by the potential health implications!We immediately returned to the restaurant and were given a refund (still pending). We were offered a free meal but declined.Understandably, we would never feel safe or comfortable eating food from here again. Please see photos for reference. Read more

One word to describe this place is "awesome". From the second that we set foot through the door we were greeted by the owner... Gino. He treated us like regulars even though it was our first time, he also treated or four legged children with love and care.This place is dog friendly inside and out in the patio. It is nice seeing a owner of an establishment show so much passion fortheir restaurant. Our waiter Dallan was excellent she took care of our every need with a smile. As for the food the pizza wasdelicious we had their Hawaiian and BBQ chicken. We also had their garlic bread which was amazing. To end the night we had anincredible cannoli Overall this place is great and we will be returning here time and time again. Read more