Reviews for Matt the Miller's Tavern in Carmel, IN
Amazing food! We were staying in Carmel for the night and found this place for dinner. Such a great location and great food!
A good spot for dinner. Easy going. Solid good. Good staff. The evening crowd seems gets towards a singles bar but not in a bad... way. Restaurant isn’t negatively affected by that. Read more
Thank you for a lovely dining experience. The food was delicious and served in a timely manner. We especially appreciated the... friendly atmosphere of the establishment due in large part to our server, Sophie. We asked a lot of questions about the menu andgrilled her over the gluten free options. Sophie answered readily and was never ruffled by our bantering. We’ll definitely askfor Sophie each time we return. Read more
Food was better than expected, steak was good and the salad was great. Broccoli I had was served raw. Also, I’m pretty sure... there was a Geriatrics Anonymous meeting going on or something… I was the only one there under 65. Maybe just onTuesdays? Tuesday steak deal was not a bad deal, but the steak was not prime. Overall, was decent. I would not take my ownguests there, but if someone proposed to go there for a meal I would not oppose. Read more
One of my top places to eat, after only visiting one time most recently! The food is tasty, to reiterate the food is tasty and... it is seasoned to my wife's and I liking. Very courteous, helpful, knowledgeable, and kind waiters! We ate outside, we did noteven have the pleasure of eating inside. I can Only imagine the kind of service that we would gotten inside. Thank you for thatexperience. FYI .... the Cod is fulfilling and very good! Read more
Came here on a nice day to sit on their patio. It was a really spacious patio in the shade of the building during the afternoon.... I ordered the chicken sandwich and their margarita on special that day. The margaritas came out first and was not reallyimpressed with them as they tasted like the overly sweet premixed ones. The chicken sandwich though was great! Very juicy andcomes with a side of fries. It was well worth the trip alone. Overall Miller’s was a really convenient location with excellentprices for the area. The food quality was really good but they have a extensive beer selection that I will try next time. Read more
Good meal and nice atmosphere. Dined outside with friends. Had the grilled salmon. The dish was good, but had a lot going on.... Almost too much on the plate and lots of competing flavors (some pretty spicy). Service was good, although they did seem to bea little short-staffed for a Friday night crowd. All in all, a good experience, and we will likely return. Read more
We went to this place while visiting the Carmel palladium to see Christmas decorations and Christkindlmarkt, The place is busy... on weekends but we booked ahead of time with open table. We ordered Spiked punch as our drink. Since we were there during happyhour, we decided to order from that menu. We ordered pretzel bites and Buffalo chicken strips. The price of these items was lessthan dinner menu items as they were listed on happy hour menu but the quantity was also adjusted accordingly. For us it workedout as it was just two of us. We loved the sauce and dips that came with these dishes. We also ordered tomato bisque soup sndmushroom flatbread from dinner menu. The soup was ok but flatbread was perfect. The best part was it not covered with greaselike we get at other places. Parking was not an issue, The menu have good choices for vegetarians like me. They offer valetparking and there is garage parking available as well. The ambience of this place was warm and cozy perfect for winter weather.Bathroom is small given the size of the place but very well maintained and clean. I will definitely go back here again, thistime may be for lunch. Only reason for four stars is that the service was slow that day. Read more