Reviews for Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria in Carol Stream, IL

We always get our thin crust pizzas here. We recently switched from the local Lou Malnatis to Marciano's for our Chicago deep... dish pizza, too. I know. First one was double cheese, half bacon half spinach. Excellent, but spinach was a bit plain, and baconwas a bit greasy. Just got a double cheese, half spinach and light garlic, and half bacon, precooked special order. They said,Sure, no problem. It was delicious. Sauce was a little heavy this time though. Best pizza that delivers in West Chicago area. Read more

While the pepperoni calzone and chicken parm sandwich were good, we also ordered 2 pastas with an add on of shrimp each. The... shrimp was 6 dollars addition each, of which when we opened our dishes saw that they were the salad shrimp, not normal shrimp.I've never seen anyone use salad shrimp in a pasta dish, within a restaurant, especially about 1/2 to 1 Oz worth. I don't knowhow this is acceptable to serve, expecting actual size shrimp. Hopefully this can be addressed/changed in the future. We haveaddressed our concerns with the restaurant, but wanted to address this concern publicly as well. Read more

Best Chicago style deep-dish, period. Their side salads are huge and awesome, the bread and olive oil is a nice starter, and... they have some decent wine a good price. My favorite place to get a deep dish pizza meal. If you're not wanting pizza, theirTortellini alla Vodka is spicy and excellent. Read more

Pizza sauce was good. I ordered the tiramisu,$5.38 with tax and it was the size of a pizza square? truly small. The kids ... working there probably run the place since I didn?t see any adult while the cashier was having issues with her register.Otherthan that it?s the closest pizza place to my house most likely will be ordering again. Delivery only. Read more

I loved the food this place had! We took a garlic bread and raviolis which were hot and fresh. The pizza took quite a bit of... time to come but when it did it was delicious. Definitely one of the best pizza restaurants I?ve ever ate from. Definitely worthtrying. 5/5 Read more

I was really looking forward to this place, unfortunately we were pretty disappointed tonight. We ordered an Italian Beef,... Lasagna, Calamari, a Pizza, and Fries. On a positive note, the pizza and beef were great! The calamari was horrible. Totally under cooked and almost no breading at all. It had the consistency of a wet noodle. The lasagna was undercooked. Itwas still luke warm in the middle. Obviously it's pre-made and warmed up when ordered, but it shouldn't be hard to make sureit's hot before serving it. The fries were flat out cold and inedible. Very disappointing. Read more

We ordered a16" thin crust "Works" pizza to get a 12" cheese pizza free. (Great coupons) First of all, we were happy that they... were open on Memorial Day. We had plans to grill but due to a plumbing emergency found ourselves in need of dinner. Marcianosto the rescue! As always the pizza was very good. The crust is nice the sauce is always just right the cheese was wonderful andplenty of meat. The only thing we felt there wasn't enough of was mushroom. A bit of the bacon was concentrated in the center ofthe pizza rather than spread around making a couple of pieces a bit salty but overall still a great pizza. The only other reasonI gave it a four-star rather than a five star was that it seems a bit pricey. $34 for a pizza seems a little bit much. But thenagain maybe I?m just out of the loop. I don?t order them often. Staff are always friendly and our pizza was ready when wearrived to pick it up. We usually dine in and order meals rather than pizza. We have always had good meals and good service. Thedinners are very reasonably priced and delicious. Read more

Fast service but we ended up getting meatballs that were super pink all the way through and bloody! The eggplant sandwich was... chewy like they microwaved it. This was so disappointing!! We called and they offered a credit for half off a pasta dish ascompensation. Uhhhh no thanks, I don?t think we will be giving you another chance. Read more