Reviews for Shirky's Pizza Zone in Carroll, OH
Owners as well as the staff are awesome, always friendly and helpful. Food is always excellent.
If your close to Carroll, stop in for some fantastic pizza, they have a great dough, to create an incredible crust and the... cupping pepperoni is the best around...take out or dine in, give it a try!!! Keep up the great work! Be sure to take care ofthe hard working staff...they are awesome!!! **We stopped in tonight on a busy Friday night, Terry recognized us( one of theowners) and grabbed a towel and spray bottle to clean a table. Another great evening, great pizza as always...too bad you can'tsell your customer service to the rest of the world. Hats off to our server, Tylar, she is great, funny and a hardworker... Keep up the good work!!! Read more
First time here, definitely not our last! We had wings, Buffalo chicken dip and pizza! Everything was absolutely perfect! Also,... great service! Thank you! Read more
My pizza was not very good. I was expecting more with all good reviews. It was pretty bland tasting I thought.
I asked my Hubby to grab a pizza on the way home and he just happened to be close to Shirky's. We never had it before and I am... REALLY picky about my Pizza. I absolutely LOVE this pizza!!! I will go out of my way to have it again! Read more
My wife and I loved the pizzas we purchased and ate in our vehicle. It was our first visit and we didn't realize that it had a... dining area. We ordered take out and sat in the shade enjoying our food. Yummy Read more
Glad I expanded my search for pizza places to further out into Southeast Columbus. Shirky's is wonderful. Nestled in what... looks like uptown Carrol Ohio, it's a carryout and bar - didn't visit the bar just placed a carryout order. Staff was extremelynice, even chatted it up and made some welcome recommendations while I was waiting for my pickup order. Ordered a mediummushroom pizza, medium buffalo chicken dip pizza, large pepperoni and onion pizza, gluten free pepperoni pizza, an order ofwings with garlic sauce, an order of fried pickles, and an Italian sub. All of that was $68, which is quite reasonable. Thepizzas were similar to other Columbus/Midwest style pizza and had flavorful sauce, cooked to perfection, and excellent toppings. It reminded me of pizza that's a little thicker than Classic's. Their buffalo chicken dip pizza was very unique anddelicious. Sister in law is intolerant to gluten and got the gluten free pepperoni, she said it was one of the better glutenfree pizzas she's had - crust was thicker than most gluten free crusts and the pepperoni was the smaller cupped old world. TheItalian sub was good, wouldn't say top 5 or anything, but still tasty. The fried pickles weren't chips, but rather slices ofSpears with a bit of spice, and were very good. Wings were average. Overall I'd give the pizza a 4.8 out of 5, the appetizersand sub a 4.5 out of 5 and the wings a 4 out of 5. Because of how good the pizza was, the reasonable prices, and thefriendliness of the staff I've rounded up to a 5 since Google doesn't allow decimal reviews. Read more
Great atmosphere, great pie, and Natalie our server was amazing!