Reviews for Big Bill's New York Pizza in Centennial, CO
Big Bill it's time to take a trip back home to Long Island and maybe get a refresher on the whole pizzeria thing. These garlic... knots would be the punchline to every bad food joke in nassau county. Just some dense dough, no oil and not a spec of parsley.Basically just bread balls with "garlic" on top. The lemon chicken should be sponsored by Exxon for the amount of oil that wason the bottom. The pizza is a colorado 7/10 and a NY/LI 1/10. I had really high hopes coming here and I'm left with anothercolorado pizza letdown Read more
Excellent pizza, it might be the closest to NY style in the Denver area. The sauce is good and the flavor and dough are... excellent. Read more
Best NY style pizza in Colorado! Always delicious. Always excellent service. Small town feel. We moved so it's been awhile since... going there recently but they still remember us. Also, their gluten free crust is really good and they now have dairy freecheese which is hard to find for my dairy sensitive child. She was so happy to have cheese on her pizza! Read more
Being from the east coast, my standards for pizza are high. Big Bill's meets and/or exceeds my standards with their food, for... sure! The NY style pizza and a ton of other items I've tried off the menu are the best I've had since moving here a few yearsago. The atmosphere is pretty dope and reminds me of a typical style NYC pizza joint in the 80s/90s. Don't worry, they haveplenty of HD TVs, though! If you like pizza, definitely give this place a shot! Read more
I've had the white, plain cheese and veggie pies. The white and plain cheese are consistently good, but both times I've ordered... the veggie they have come out mushy and wet. Read more
Great pizza place, clean spacious with room for families. No mask required, the restaurant crew that we saw, generally wasn't... masked. The garlic bread is unique, in that it definitely is more of a homemade affair. The supreme pizza was pretty good too.Give them a try! Read more
We got the Combo pizza. The toppings, or lack there of, were thinly sliced and taste like hot lettuce. Have you ever brought a... burger home, put it on the fridge, warmed it up the next day and tasted the ?plastic like? texture lettuce. Best way to describethese veggies. It was also topped off and smothered in cheese, It did not taste good at all. The crust of the pizza was the bestpart. I also got a house salad, the lettuce and veggies were dried up and probably sitting in the fridge for days. It was notfresh at all. I won?t eat here again. Read more
The place was hoppin'. The service was extremely excellent. We had the chopped dinner salad and the small combo pizza with the... whole wheat crust. It was the best pizza I have had in a long time. I highly recommend this place. Read more