Reviews for Atlantic Seafood in Center Moriches, NY
Very slow service but food was was pretty good , the muscles were not prepared properly , with white wine or parsley, just... garlic and chicken stock, we spent 256.00 for 3 people. 14.00 for watery rum punch ,and not one single comp, so when the dessertwas a child?s portion size for 10.00 , I was very disappointed in that , that scores a lot of points with me when you appreciateyour customer spending loads of money for mediocre food. very cheap and petty!!!! Read more
Really good fresh clams!!! And the kiddos loved entering into the sharks mouth though we couldn?t ?get the shot? haha dining w... toddlers?.. Read more
I grew up next town over so I?ve been coming here since I was a kid. I?d suggest to ownership take down the ?ribs? and ?nachos?... on the sign and put up a big neon sign about the LOCAL fried flounder sandwich! Best one I?ve ever eaten, seriously and it stillis like the one I had as a kid, wow! Below is the clam bake, with steamers in there, THAT?S LONG ISLAND! Read more
If you have never been before, you need to read this review to be prepared. Food was good (albeit pricey). Payment policy... (they do not take certain CCs) is antiquated. Also, bring cash if you want to leave a tip as you literally have to tell thewaitress how much you plan on tipping if you pay with CC. Staff seemed cold (other than our waitress who was somewhat kind). Do not go during peak hours as it gets tight and uncomfortable. Read more
Wow.. WOW.. If i could give 10 Stars they definitely deserve it. From The friendly host to the AMAZING waitress Eileen to the... bus boys all was SPECTACULAR. We frequently go Out and try new restaurants and WOW just amazing at Atlantic Seafood. The best isthat they are just 10 Minutes from Home. So we will Be regulars now. We had chicken fingers (A MUST) , calamari, shrimpplatter, lobster roll ( $40 SO WORTH IT) was better than the one I had two weeks ago in Montauk. BBQ smokehouse was absolutelydelicious? RUN PUNCH out of this world. The customer service was splendid. Truly appreciate the service. Food is cooked freshso may be a wait but TOTALLY WORTH IT. Read more
Excellent. Enjoyed lobster bisque, fried calamari, soft shell crabs, and blackened shrimp wrap. All were delicious. Loads of... fries came with both entrees. Food was served hot off the grill. Amazing find while camping, will be back again. Indoor andoutdoor dining available. Staff were pleasant and attentive. Recomend highly. Read more
Decided to stop here for a yummy bite after a beach day! Had really high hopes for a lovely meal considering all of the other... reviews. Unfortunately, the food was subpar at best. The lobster nachos were smothered with a tasteless cheese and mostlytomatoes disguised as lobster chunks. Our meals were edible but not worth the prices. The tacos were alright , but the crab cakesandwich was mushy and barely tasted of crab, definitely frozen!! Everything is served in and on plastic which makes no senseconsidering the insane prices. With the ocean only steps away I would imagine that the seafood would be fresh and delicious!Won?t be returning here anytime soon. Read more
This was a great lil place! The food was delicious, great menu to choose from, food was fresh and tasty only problem was the... service was slow, we waited a while for our dinner, the waitstaff was friendly, but we were starving before the food came out!Would recommend as the food freshness made up for the wait, there was also a convenient pick up/ take out, busy service station,I saw many people bringing food home, maybe that's why the service was so slow. Overall, I would go back, plenty of seating andbig parking lot, local restaurant right off Montauk Hwy in Moriches, NY. Read more