Reviews for Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Centereach, NY

Just had an amazing shrimp parmesan dinner the sauce was so flavorful and thick. It wasn't like some other places I've been to... where it's watery. I highly recommend them you won't be disappointed. Read more

My usual place was closed and this place popped up so I decided to give it a try.Let me just say that I regret it, this has to... be the worst chicken parmigiana spaghetti I have ever eaten. The chicken was extremely crunchy and rough where when you chew ittasted like rubber, and the spaghetti is more like Angel hair very thin. The cheese was hard and the sauce had no flavor. Thiswas very bland. What makes it worst is that it wasn?t cheap either,extremely disappointing since I was looking forward to eatingsomething good. Read more

We went with a large party and they were extremely accommodating to have us all in one large table. Overall, the bread was so... fresh and the salads were amazing. Unfortunately, we had a few people not crazy about the actual meals; the eggplant, the veal,the pasta pomodoro. Also there were no prices on the menu we were told to scan the code to see prices but a couple of thingscame up more on the bill and we were told it wasn't updated. Another small lack of communication was when we asked for water,we didn't realize it was a water bottle and cost $1.50. Maybe the pizza gets better reviews than the actual dinners here. Weoften eat at another Italian restaurant and we did notice a difference in the quality of the meals. I wish we could say, weloved it because they were so accommodating. Also we were over the 8 people limit so we couldn't have the 3 course special andwe were very disappointed. I almost asked if we could have had one table at 8 and one at 6, separate checks and then maybe wecould have. The bill was so hard to divide being 14 people anyway. Sorry RonkonkomaMoms, and LI Eat and Drink, I wish I had abetter experience. Read more

Michael Anthony's is the best Italian restaurant in town The food is the freshest and the staff is friendly and makes coming... here a pleasure. This family owned business is what makes your experience worth it all the more. They treat you like family andthe prices make you feel like you're getting the family discount. Read more

Great local pizzeria :) Deleted previous not so great review because the owners response was amazing. We all make mistakes ,... it?s about how we fix them! Acknowledgement, great service , great food are all part of why patrons come back. PS ; theirgrandma was delicious! Ahhh, pesto is a nice touch. Che bello Read more

Food was under cooked. I ordered a family combo meal with 1 pizza which was under cooked and doughy. The Baked ziti I also... received was Inedible and was not cooked all the way through. The chicken parm hero i got was cooked fine but was cold by thetime i was able to eat it. The garlic knot was rock hard and only could eat the bottom of it. When called about it they couldnot help me in any way due to me buying through their site recommended online ordering system which they do not control (buyerbeware). I will not be ever going back to this establishment which i would frequent in the past. Many other local pizza shopsaround that you can do business with instead. Read more

Crazy prices! $28 for 1 pie, half meatball and 6 garlic knots?? Pizza is the cheapest food to make! $12 over priced easily. Not... sure If I will go back. So close too, 0.6 miles away. Such a shame. Lower cost, high volume works better. Food was deliciousthough, just too costly. Read more

We had our daughters baby shower there yesterday and they were absolutely AMAZING!!! Can't say enough great things about our... hostess Kristine and the absolute amazing job she did!! The food was beyond great and they accommodated the few vegans we hadas well! Can not thank them enough! It's a MUST GO TO stop if you haven't been! Read more